Before you begin
How to work through this
Here's the whole study in one sentence: the Church came before the Bible, not the other way around, and when you take the Bible out of the Church's hands, every reader ends up as the final judge of what it means.
Questions this study answers
- What is sola scriptura?
- The teaching that Scripture interprets itself and each reader applies it. The question was never whether the Bible is true. It's who tells you what it means. Session 1 →
- Which came first, the Church or the Bible?
- The Church. It was preaching, baptizing and settling disputes for years before Paul sent his first letter, and its members wrote the New Testament to churches that already existed. Session 2 →
- Does the Bible tell us to keep oral tradition?
- Yes. The apostles told the Church to hold the traditions they handed down, "whether by word or our epistle," and to pass them on to faithful men. Session 3 →
- Who decided which books are in the Bible?
- No verse lists the books of Scripture. The Church settled which books belong and handed the answer down, and the apostles read the Septuagint. Session 4 →
- Who has the authority to interpret Scripture?
- Scripture calls the Church "the pillar and ground of the truth." The first time a fight over Scripture split the Church, a council settled it, not each reader. Session 5 →
There are seven sessions. Each one starts with the passages to read before anything else. Open a Bible and read them first, in order, before you read a word of what I have to say. The key passages are printed here in full, so you never have to take anybody's word for what a text says.
What "the Bible" means here. When this study says "the Bible," it means the Old and New Testaments together as one book, with a settled list of what belongs in it. That book didn't exist when the Church was born. The apostles preached Christ from the Old Testament Scriptures and by word of mouth. The New Testament got written over the next few decades, by members of the Church, to churches that were already there. And the list of which books belong was handed down and spelled out by the Church centuries later. In Session 4 you'll see a bishop writing that list out in AD 367.
The Fathers carry the argument. Every point in this study stands on Scripture and on the Fathers of the early Church, and you'll find their words right where they apply. Here's who you'll hear from: St Irenaeus of Lyons, who learned the faith from St Polycarp, who learned it from the apostles. Tertullian in Carthage. St Cyril in Jerusalem. St Athanasius in Alexandria. St Basil in Cappadocia. St John Chrysostom, preaching verse by verse through Paul. St Augustine in Hippo. St Vincent of Lérins. St John of Damascus.
The Councils and later Fathers show the faith never changed. The Seventh Ecumenical Council in 787, the Synod of Jerusalem in 1672, and St Philaret of Moscow's catechism all say what the early Fathers said, century after century.
Modern Orthodox writers back it up. Fr Seraphim Rose and Fr John Whiteford get quoted after the Fathers, confirming what the Church has always taught. Fr John was raised in the Church of the Nazarene and came to Orthodoxy over exactly this question.
A word about "Catholic"
Whenever the Fathers, the Councils or this study say "Catholic," the word means what it originally meant: universal, the whole Church throughout the world. It doesn't mean the Roman Catholic Church. St Vincent of Lérins defines it himself: that is "truly and in the strictest sense 'Catholic,' which, as the name itself and the reason of the thing declare, comprehends all universally" (Commonitory 2.6).
The New Testament writers quote the Old all the time, usually without saying where it's from. Whenever an apostle is arguing from a text you can't see, a blue panel prints the passage behind it. In Session 4 those panels are where the argument turns: twice, the apostles quote the Old Testament the way the Greek Septuagint has it, not the way most English Bibles have it.
Every Scripture reference on this page is a link. Click any of them and you can read the whole passage.
Go at your own pace. A session takes about forty minutes to read carefully, and longer to really think through. You can mark each one finished as you go, and the page will remember where you left off.
The translation
Scripture is quoted from the New King James Version as it appears in the Orthodox Study Bible. Its Old Testament follows the Septuagint, the Greek Old Testament the apostles quote. When the Septuagint's wording is printed on its own, it's from Sir Lancelot Brenton's translation (1851).
The seven sessions at a glance
| # | The session | What it establishes |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Who Decides? | Sola scriptura in its own confession's words, next to the Orthodox answer. Under one, the reader is the final judge. Under the other, the Church reads and the reader receives. |
| 2 | The Church Before the New Testament | The apostles preached before they ever wrote. Whole nations believed "without paper or ink." |
| 3 | Hold the Traditions | The apostles told the Church to keep what they handed down, by word and by letter alike. |
| 4 | Who Handed You the Bible? | The apostles read the Septuagint, and the list of books is something the Church handed down. |
| 5 | The Pillar and Ground of the Truth | The Church decides, not the individual reader. It's been that way from the Council of Jerusalem on, through bishops you can name all the way back to the apostles. |
| 6 | Do You Understand What You Are Reading? | Scripture doesn't interpret itself, and the sacraments are the test case. |
| 7 | When Every Reader Decides | The fruit: division that never ends, and founders who read for themselves and started their own churches. |
Session one
Who Decides?
Read these first, in this order
2 Peter 1:19–21 · Acts 15:1–2 · 1 Timothy 3:14–15 · 2 Thessalonians 2:15 · Proverbs 3:5–7
Every Christian says the Scriptures are the inspired Word of God. The question isn't whether the Bible is true. The question is who tells you what it means. And sola scriptura, in the words of its own confession, answers: the Scripture interprets itself, and the reader applies it.
St Vincent of Lérins: the rule the Church was given
"I have often then inquired earnestly and attentively of very many men eminent for sanctity and learning, how and by what sure and so to speak universal rule I may be able to distinguish the truth of Catholic faith from the falsehood of heretical pravity; and I have always, and in almost every instance, received an answer to this effect: That whether I or any one else should wish to detect the frauds and avoid the snares of heretics as they rise, and to continue sound and complete in the Catholic faith, we must, the Lord helping, fortify our own belief in two ways; first, by the authority of the Divine Law, and then, by the Tradition of the Catholic Church."
Commonitory 2.4 (AD 434)
That's the Church's answer to this session's question. It comes from a fifth-century monk who asked the holiest and most learned men he could find, and got the same answer "in almost every instance." Scripture and the Church's Tradition, together. Sola scriptura keeps the first one and drops the second.
The cleanest place to see sola scriptura spelled out is the Westminster Confession of Faith. The Westminster Assembly drew it up in the 1640s, and it's still the doctrinal standard for Presbyterian churches. Its first chapter is about Holy Scripture. Here are four of its sections, exactly as they were written.
4. The authority of the Holy Scripture, for which it ought to be believed and obeyed, dependeth not upon the testimony of any man or church, but wholly upon God (who is truth itself), the author thereof…
6. The whole counsel of God, concerning all things necessary for his own glory, man's salvation, faith, and life, is either expressly set down in Scripture, or by good and necessary consequence may be deduced from Scripture: unto which nothing at any time is to be added, whether by new revelations of the Spirit or traditions of men.
9. The infallible rule of interpretation of Scripture is the Scripture itself; and therefore, when there is a question about the true and full sense of any Scripture (which is not manifold, but one), it may be searched and known by other places that speak more clearly.
10. The Supreme Judge, by whom all controversies of religion are to be determined, and all decrees of councils, opinions of ancient writers, doctrines of men, and private spirits, are to be examined, and in whose sentence we are to rest, can be no other but the Holy Spirit speaking in the Scripture.Westminster Confession of Faith (1646), chapter 1
Now go through them in order and ask one question of each: who actually does this?
Section 9 says that when a passage is unclear, you figure it out by going to other places that "speak more clearly." Okay, but who decides which places are the clear ones? Section 10 says councils and the "opinions of ancient writers" have to be checked against the Spirit speaking in Scripture. So who does the checking? And who gets to say what the Spirit is saying in the verse they're checking it against? The Confession never names that person, and it doesn't have to. It's you, the reader. Or it's your pastor, and let's be real, his authority is just one more reader's.
That's all of sola scriptura in one line: the reader is the last court of appeal. Not the Church that wrote the New Testament. Not the councils that defended the faith. Not the Fathers who died for it. They all get "examined," and the one doing the examining is whoever's holding the book.
The Orthodox answer, in a catechism's words
Now put the Longer Catechism of St Philaret of Moscow next to Westminster. The Holy Synod of the Russian Church looked it over and approved it in the nineteenth century, and generations of Orthodox Christians learned the faith from it. It asks the same question from the other side.
16. How is divine revelation spread among men and preserved in the true Church? — By two channels—holy tradition and holy Scripture.
17. What is meant by the name holy tradition? — By the name holy tradition is meant the doctrine of the faith, the law of God, the sacraments, and the ritual as handed down by the true believers and worshipers of God by word and example from one to another, and from generation to generation.
24. Why is tradition necessary even now? — As a guide to the right understanding of holy Scripture, for the right ministration of the sacraments, and the preservation of sacred rites and ceremonies in the purity of their original institution.
56. What rules must we observe in reading holy Scripture? — …thirdly, we must take and understand it in such sense as agrees with the interpretation of the orthodox Church and the holy Fathers.The Longer Catechism of St Philaret of Moscow, questions 16, 17, 24, 56
Put the two side by side and you've got the question of this whole study on one page.
| The question | Westminster (1646) | St Philaret's Catechism |
|---|---|---|
| How does revelation reach us? | "Expressly set down in Scripture, or by good and necessary consequence" deduced from it (1.6). | "By two channels—holy tradition and holy Scripture" (Q16). |
| What interprets Scripture? | "The Scripture itself" (1.9). | "The interpretation of the orthodox Church and the holy Fathers" (Q56). |
| Who is the final judge? | "The Holy Spirit speaking in the Scripture," with councils and ancient writers "examined" (1.10). | The Church, "the pillar and ground of the truth" (Q18; 1 Timothy 3:15). |
| What about the sacraments? | Not addressed in chapter 1. | Tradition is necessary "for the right ministration of the sacraments" (Q24). |
Notice where the difference really is. Both sides say the Scriptures are inspired. Both appeal to the Holy Spirit. The difference is where you hear the Spirit interpreting: in the individual reading alone, or in the Church that's been reading these books together since before they were ever bound into one.
The Church had already named it
The idea that a Christian is only bound by what the Scriptures "evidently" say didn't show up for the first time in the sixteenth century. The Church had run into it before, coming out of the mouths of the heresiarchs.
The Second Council of Nicaea (787): a confession it received
"Anathema to those who spurn the teachings of the holy Fathers and the tradition of the Catholic Church, taking as a pretext and making their own the arguments of Arius, Nestorius, Eutyches, and Dioscorus, that unless we were evidently taught by the Old and New Testaments, we should not follow the teachings of the holy Fathers and of the holy Ecumenical Synods, and the tradition of the Catholic Church."
Acts of the Seventh Ecumenical Council, Session 1 — the confession of Basil, bishop of Ancyra
Basil of Ancyra had sided with the iconoclasts, and he came to the Council asking to be received back into communion. The confession he read made him anathematize this exact argument, and Patriarch Tarasius answered for the Council: "This whole sacred gathering yields glory and thanks to God for this confession of yours, which you have made to the Catholic Church." Look whose argument they say it is: Arius, Nestorius, Eutyches and Dioscorus. By 787 the Church had already seen where "only what the Testaments evidently teach" leads, and it put their names on it.
The first time the East answered
This isn't a new argument. About thirty years after Luther died, Lutheran theologians at Tübingen wrote to the Ecumenical Patriarch, Jeremias II of Constantinople, and laid out their principle. Fr John Whiteford quotes their letter:
Therefore, no better way could ever be found to interpret the Scriptures, other than that Scripture be interpreted by Scripture, that is to say, through itself. For the entire Scripture has been dictated by the one and the same Spirit, who best understands his own will and is best able to state His own meaning.The Tübingen theologians to Patriarch Jeremias II, quoted by Fr John Whiteford, Sola Scriptura: In the Vanity of Their Minds
And here's how the Patriarch answered:
Let us accept, then, the traditions of the Church with a sincere heart and not a multitude of rationalizations. For God created man to be upright; instead they sought after diverse ways of rationalizing (Ecclesiastes 7:29). Let us not allow ourselves to learn a new kind of faith which is condemned by the tradition of the Holy Fathers.Patriarch Jeremias II to the Tübingen theologians, quoted by Fr John Whiteford
Fr Whiteford puts his finger on what the Lutherans were really claiming. They read the Fathers, he says, but whenever the Fathers and Scripture seemed to clash, the Fathers got set aside. In practice that meant "when the teachings of the Holy fathers conflict with their private opinions on the Scriptures, their private opinions were to be considered more authoritative than the Fathers of the Church." That's Westminster 1.10 in action, seventy years before Westminster.
Fr John Whiteford is a modern Orthodox priest who was an associate pastor in the Church of the Nazarene before he became Orthodox. He points out that Protestant bodies disagree about almost everything except this: they "generally do agree on how one is to interpret the Bible — on your own! — apart from Church Tradition."
The Synod of Jerusalem (1672): not otherwise than as the Church has interpreted
"We believe the Divine and Sacred Scriptures to be God-taught; and, therefore, we ought to believe the same without doubting; yet not otherwise than as the Catholic Church hath interpreted and delivered the same. For every foul heresy receiveth, indeed, the Divine Scriptures, but perversely interpreteth the same…"
Confession of Dositheus, Decree 2, tr. J. N. W. B. Robertson (1899)
A century after Tübingen, the Orthodox bishops met at Jerusalem under Patriarch Dositheus to answer Calvinist teaching that was being passed off as the faith of the East. Their reasoning is all of Session 7 in one sentence: were the Scriptures received otherwise, "each man holding every day a different sense concerning the same," the Church "would be rent into innumerable parties."
The circle no one can step out of
So ask the question the Confession can't answer from inside itself: where does Scripture teach sola scriptura? If the doctrine is true, then by its own rule it has to be "expressly set down in Scripture, or by good and necessary consequence" deduced from it (1.6). Fr Whiteford answers it straight: "there is not one single verse in the entirety of Holy Scripture that teaches the doctrine of Sola Scriptura… there are innumerable places in the Bible that speak of its inspiration, of its authority, and of its profitability — but there is no place in the Bible that teaches that only Scripture is authoritative for believers." And when Scripture does speak to the question, it says the opposite: "hold the traditions which you were taught, whether by word or our epistle" (2 Thessalonians 2:15).
Then there's 2 Peter 1:20, which you read at the top of this session. It speaks right to the question of who interprets: "no prophecy of Scripture is of any private interpretation." Session 6 comes back to this verse. For now, just notice that Peter doesn't say "every reader may interpret for himself, guided by the clearer passages." He says the opposite.
Sit with these
- Westminster 1.9 says you understand unclear passages by going to "other places that speak more clearly." Who decides which passages are the clear ones?
- Westminster 1.10 says councils and "opinions of ancient writers" get examined. Who examines them? And whose reading of Scripture do they use to do it?
- St Philaret says tradition is necessary "for the right ministration of the sacraments." Why would a sacrament need more than a text to be done right?
- The Tübingen theologians said Scripture interprets itself. Within a generation, their own heirs were split on baptism and the Lord's Supper. What does that tell you about the principle?
- Read 2 Peter 1:20 again. Whose interpretation is it ruling out?
Carry this
Sola scriptura doesn't get rid of the interpreter. It makes you the interpreter, and the final one. The Church's answer is older: the Scriptures are read, understood and handed on inside the Church that was reading them before they were ever bound into one book.
Session two
The Church Before the New Testament
Read these first, in this order
Luke 1:1–4 · Acts 2:36–47 · 1 Corinthians 15:1–4 · Acts 17:10–12 · John 20:30–31 · John 21:24–25
On the day of Pentecost three thousand people were baptized, and they "continued steadfastly in the apostles' doctrine." Not one book of the New Testament had been written yet. The Church was preaching, baptizing, breaking bread and settling disputes for years before Paul sent his first letter. And it was members of that Church who wrote the New Testament, to churches that were already there.
Handed down, then written down
Start where Luke starts. Before he writes a word of his Gospel, he tells you where his material came from.
1 Inasmuch as many have taken in hand to set in order a narrative of those things which have been fulfilled among us, 2 just as those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and ministers of the word delivered them to us, 3 it seemed good to me also, having had perfect understanding of all things from the very first, to write to you an orderly account, most excellent Theophilus, 4 that you may know the certainty of those things in which you were instructed.Luke 1:1–4
There are three things in these four verses. First, what Luke writes was delivered by eyewitnesses before he ever wrote it. The Greek verb is paredosan, from the same root as paradosis, "tradition." Second, Theophilus had already been instructed. The Greek there is katēchēthēs, which is where we get the word "catechism." Third, Luke writes so Theophilus can know for sure that what he'd already been taught is true. The Gospel confirms the catechesis. It doesn't replace it.
Paul says the same thing about the Resurrection itself: "For I delivered to you first of all that which I also received: that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures" (1 Corinthians 15:3). Delivered and received. The gospel got passed hand to hand before Paul ever wrote it to Corinth. And the "Scriptures" Christ died according to are the Old Testament, because those were the only Scriptures there were yet.
And here are the first Christians, before any of it was written down:
And they continued steadfastly in the apostles' doctrine and fellowship, in the breaking of bread, and in prayers.Acts 2:42
The apostles' doctrine, the fellowship, the breaking of bread, the prayers. That's a Church with teaching, communion, a Eucharist and a liturgy of prayer. And no New Testament.
St Irenaeus of Lyons: first preached, then written
"We have learned from none others the plan of our salvation, than from those through whom the Gospel has come down to us, which they did at one time proclaim in public, and, at a later period, by the will of God, handed down to us in the Scriptures, to be the ground and pillar of our faith."
Against Heresies III.1.1
Irenaeus was bishop of Lyons in the second century, and he walks you through it: Matthew issued a written Gospel "while Peter and Paul were preaching at Rome, and laying the foundations of the Church"; Mark "did also hand down to us in writing what had been preached by Peter"; Luke "recorded in a book the Gospel preached by" Paul; and "afterwards, John… did himself publish a Gospel during his residence at Ephesus." Every time, the preaching comes first and the writing follows. The apostles wrote down what the Church was already living.
St Philaret of Moscow: which is older?
"The most ancient and original instrument for spreading divine revelation is holy tradition. From Adam to Moses there were no sacred books. Our Lord Jesus Christ himself delivered his divine doctrine and ordinances to his Disciples by word and example, but not by writing. The same method was followed by the Apostles also at first, when they spread abroad the faith and established the Church of Christ."
Longer Catechism, question 21
Christ didn't write a book. He founded a Church, taught His apostles by word and example, and sent them out. The one time the Gospels show Him writing anything, He writes on the ground (John 8:6–8), and nobody records what He wrote.
Believers without paper or ink
Irenaeus follows that out to the obvious question. If the Scriptures were the only way to know the faith, then until they were written, collected and copied, nobody could know the faith at all. Right? He answers by pointing to the Church of his own day.
St Irenaeus of Lyons: if the apostles had left no writings
"Suppose there arise a dispute relative to some important question among us, should we not have recourse to the most ancient Churches with which the apostles held constant intercourse, and learn from them what is certain and clear in regard to the present question? For how should it be if the apostles themselves had not left us writings? Would it not be necessary, [in that case,] to follow the course of the tradition which they handed down to those to whom they did commit the Churches? To which course many nations of those barbarians who believe in Christ do assent, having salvation written in their hearts by the Spirit, without paper or ink, and, carefully preserving the ancient tradition…"
Against Heresies III.4.1–2
And here's what he says about those nations: "Those who, in the absence of written documents, have believed this faith, are barbarians, so far as regards our language; but as regards doctrine, manner, and tenor of life, they are, because of faith, very wise indeed; and they do please God." Whole peoples, in the second century, holding the whole apostolic faith, without a Bible.
Tertullian: proved by the churches the apostles founded
"Now, what that was which they preached—in other words, what it was which Christ revealed to them—can properly be proved in no other way than by those very churches which the apostles founded in person, by declaring the gospel to them directly themselves, both vivâ voce and subsequently by their epistles."
The Prescription Against Heretics 21
Vivâ voce, by the living voice, and subsequently by letter. Tertullian was writing in Carthage around the year 200, and he puts things in exactly the same order Luke and Irenaeus do.
The Bereans: testing the spoken Word
People love to use Acts 17:11 as a charter for reading the Bible on your own. So read it where it actually sits.
These were more fair-minded than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness, and searched the Scriptures daily to find out whether these things were so.Acts 17:11
What did the Bereans receive? Paul's preaching. It was spoken, in their synagogue, by an apostle standing right in front of them (Acts 17:10). What did they search? "The Scriptures," meaning the Old Testament, because there wasn't any other. The gospel came to Berea by mouth, from an apostle, and they checked it against the prophets. There's nothing in this passage about a guy alone with a Bible deciding for himself what the gospel is. It's a synagogue hearing the apostles' preaching and finding out the prophets had said it all ahead of time.
More than was written
John ends his Gospel by telling you straight out that his book isn't the whole story.
And there are also many other things that Jesus did, which if they were written one by one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books that would be written. Amen.John 21:25
He'd already said it once: "Jesus did many other signs in the presence of His disciples, which are not written in this book; but these are written that you may believe" (John 20:30–31). What got written was written for a reason: so that you'd believe. It was never meant as a complete record of everything Christ said and did and handed to His apostles.
Sit with these
- Luke 1:2 says the eyewitnesses "delivered" these things before Luke wrote them down. Delivered to who, and how?
- Acts 2:42 names four things the first Christians kept on doing. How many of them needed a New Testament?
- Irenaeus says the apostles "at one time proclaim[ed] in public, and, at a later period… handed down to us in the Scriptures." What was the Church living on in the meantime?
- What did the Bereans receive, and what did they search? Which one came to them by word of mouth?
- If whole nations in Irenaeus's day held the faith "without paper or ink," what does that tell you about where the faith lives?
Carry this
The Church preached before it wrote. The New Testament was written by the Church, inside the Church, to the Church. And the Church was already alive, teaching and breaking bread, when the first line of it was written.
Session three
Hold the Traditions
Read these first, in this order
2 Thessalonians 2:13–15 · 2 Thessalonians 3:6 · 1 Corinthians 11:2 · 1 Corinthians 11:23–26 · 2 Timothy 1:13–14 · 2 Timothy 2:1–2 · Mark 7:1–13 · Jude 3
The apostles never told the Church to keep only what they wrote. They told it to hold on to the traditions they handed down, "whether by word or our epistle." And they told it to pass those on to faithful men who would teach others too.
15 Therefore, brethren, stand fast and hold the traditions which you were taught, whether by word or our epistle.2 Thessalonians 2:15
6 But we command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you withdraw from every brother who walks disorderly and not according to the tradition which he received from us.2 Thessalonians 3:6
2 Now I praise you, brethren, that you remember me in all things and keep the traditions just as I delivered them to you.1 Corinthians 11:2
Three commands, and one word runs through all of them. In Greek it's paradosis: "what is handed over." Paul praises the Corinthians for keeping the traditions. He commands the Thessalonians to hold them. He tells them to stay away from any brother who doesn't walk according to them. The traditions aren't optional extras sitting next to the letters. Walking outside them is grounds for separation.
St John Chrysostom: "It is a tradition, seek no farther"
"Hence it is manifest, that they did not deliver all things by Epistle, but many things also unwritten, and in like manner both the one and the other are worthy of credit. Therefore let us think the tradition of the Church also worthy of credit. It is a tradition, seek no farther."
Homilies on Second Thessalonians 4, on 2 Thessalonians 2:15
The greatest preacher the Greek Church ever had, going verse by verse, reads 2 Thessalonians 2:15 exactly the way it reads. The apostles didn't hand down everything by letter. What they handed down unwritten is "in like manner" worthy of credit. And once you can show something is the Church's tradition, that settles it: "seek no farther."
What the Church kept that is not written
So what were these unwritten traditions? St Basil the Great, bishop of Caesarea in the fourth century, names some of them. And every single one is still done in the Orthodox Church today.
St Basil the Great: the same force
"Of the beliefs and practices whether generally accepted or publicly enjoined which are preserved in the Church some we possess derived from written teaching; others we have received delivered to us 'in a mystery' by the tradition of the apostles; and both of these in relation to true religion have the same force… For were we to attempt to reject such customs as have no written authority, on the ground that the importance they possess is small, we should unintentionally injure the Gospel in its very vitals… For instance, to take the first and most general example, who is thence who has taught us in writing to sign with the sign of the cross those who have trusted in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ?"
On the Holy Spirit 27.66
And he keeps going: turning to the East to pray, the words of invocation over the Eucharistic bread and cup, the blessing of the water of baptism and the oil of chrism, baptizing three times, renouncing Satan and his angels. "On what written authority do we do this? Is not our authority silent and mystical tradition?" Throw out the unwritten, Basil says, and you "injure the Gospel in its very vitals." Why? Because the Gospel was never just a text. It's the life of the Church, and a lot of that life got handed down by doing it.
St John of Damascus: much that is unwritten
"Moreover that the Apostles handed down much that was unwritten, Paul, the Apostle of the Gentiles, tells us in these words: Therefore, brethren, stand fast and hold the traditions which ye have been taught of us, whether by word or by epistle. And to the Corinthians he writes, Now I praise you, brethren, that ye remember me in all things, and keep the traditions as I have delivered them to you."
An Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith IV.16
Earlier in the same book, where he explains why Christians pray facing East, he says: "this tradition of the apostles is unwritten. For much that has been handed down to us by tradition is unwritten" (IV.12). St John is writing in the eighth century, and he reads 2 Thessalonians 2:15 the same way Chrysostom read it four hundred years earlier. He even names the same practice St Basil named.
The Second Council of Nicaea (787): whether in writing or verbally
"To make our confession short, we keep unchanged all the ecclesiastical traditions handed down to us, whether in writing or verbally…"
Decree of the Seventh Ecumenical Council
And here's how the Council described what it was doing: "Thus we follow Paul, who spoke in Christ, and the whole divine Apostolic company and the holy Fathers, holding fast the traditions which we have received." That's an Ecumenical Council of the whole Church, repeating 2 Thessalonians 2:15 as its own confession.
Tradition of men, and tradition from the Lord
Now, Christ did condemn traditions. Read all of Mark 7, and pay attention to what He condemns.
8 For laying aside the commandment of God, you hold the tradition of men—the washing of pitchers and cups, and many other such things you do.Mark 7:8
Now put that next to what Paul says about the tradition he handed down to the Corinthians about the Eucharist:
23 For I received from the Lord that which I also delivered to you: that the Lord Jesus on the same night in which He was betrayed took bread…1 Corinthians 11:23
Fr John Whiteford sums it up. The same Greek word is used for the Pharisees' traditions and the apostles', so "what makes the tradition of the Pharisees false and that of the Church true? The source!" Christ condemned traditions of men that pushed aside the commandment of God. Paul commanded the tradition he received from the Lord. If you read Mark 7 as condemning all tradition, you've put Christ at war with His own apostle.
Handed on, man to man
Paul doesn't just tell the churches to hold on to what he handed down. He tells his disciple how to keep it going after he's gone.
2 And the things that you have heard from me among many witnesses, commit these to faithful men who will be able to teach others also.2 Timothy 2:2
Count the generations in that one verse: Paul, Timothy, faithful men, others also. That's four links in a chain, and what gets passed along is what Timothy "heard." A few verses earlier Paul had told him: "Hold fast the pattern of sound words which you have heard from me… That good thing which was committed to you, keep by the Holy Spirit who dwells in us" (2 Timothy 1:13–14). And Jude calls it "the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints" (Jude 3). Delivered. Handed over, once for all.
You can see how naturally Paul himself leaned on what was handed down. In 2 Timothy 3:8 he names the two magicians who opposed Moses: "Jannes and Jambres." Their names aren't anywhere in the Old Testament. Fr Whiteford points it out: Paul "is drawing upon the oral tradition." And he does it in the very chapter people quote to prove the Bible is all a Christian needs.
Sit with these
- In 2 Thessalonians 2:15, what are the two ways the traditions were handed down? Which one does sola scriptura keep?
- 2 Thessalonians 3:6 tells believers to stay away from a brother who doesn't walk "according to the tradition." How would a Thessalonian know what that tradition was, beyond the letter in his hand?
- Basil names the sign of the cross, facing East, the Eucharistic invocation, and triple immersion. Which of these does your own church do, and where did it learn them?
- Mark 7:8 and 1 Corinthians 11:23 both talk about tradition. Where does each one come from?
- Count the links in 2 Timothy 2:2. Where does that chain end up, twenty centuries later?
Carry this
"Hold the traditions… whether by word or our epistle." The apostles handed down one faith in two forms. If you keep only the letters, you're not keeping what they handed down. You're keeping half of it, and deciding for yourself what that half means.
Session four
Who Handed You the Bible?
Read these first, in this order
Luke 24:25–27, 44–45 · Hebrews 10:1–10 · Psalm 40:6–8 · Acts 15:12–21 · Amos 9:11–12 · Matthew 1:18–23 · 2 Timothy 3:14–17
There's no verse of Scripture that lists the books of Scripture. The Bible doesn't come with an inspired table of contents. So two things had to come from the Church: which text of the Old Testament to read, and which books belong in the first place. The apostles answered the first one by reading the Septuagint. The Church answered the second one and handed the answer down.
The apostles' Old Testament
When the New Testament quotes the Old, a lot of the time it quotes it in Greek. That's the Septuagint, the translation of the Hebrew Scriptures that Jews in Alexandria made before Christ was born. Most English Bibles translate their Old Testament from the Hebrew text that Jewish scholars standardized later on, called the Masoretic text. Most of the time the two say the same thing. When they don't, you can see which one the apostles were reading.
The verse behind "a body You have prepared for Me"
Hebrews quotes Christ, coming into the world, using the words of Psalm 40:
"Therefore, when He came into the world, He said: 'Sacrifice and offering You did not desire, But a body You have prepared for Me.'"
Hebrews 10:5
Here's Psalm 40:6 the way most English Bibles have it, translated from the Hebrew:
"Sacrifice and offering You did not desire; My ears You have opened. Burnt offering and sin offering You did not require."
Psalm 40:6 · NKJV
And here's the same verse in the Septuagint, where this psalm is numbered thirty-nine:
"Sacrifice and offering thou wouldest not; but a body hast thou prepared me: whole-burnt-offering and sacrifice for sin thou didst not require."
Psalm 40:6 (Septuagint 39:7) · tr. Brenton
The apostle quotes the Septuagint. "A body You have prepared for Me" is how the Greek Old Testament reads, not the Hebrew. And it's the reading that speaks of the Incarnation: the eternal Son taking a body so He could offer Himself. The whole argument of Hebrews 10:5–10 turns on that body: "we have been sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all" (Hebrews 10:10).
The verse behind the Council of Jerusalem
At the Church's first council, James settles whether Gentiles have to be circumcised by quoting the prophet Amos:
"'After this I will return And will rebuild the tabernacle of David, which has fallen down; I will rebuild its ruins, And I will set it up; So that the rest of mankind may seek the LORD, Even all the Gentiles who are called by My name, Says the LORD who does all these things.'"
Acts 15:16–17
Here's Amos 9:12 the way most English Bibles have it, from the Hebrew:
"That they may possess the remnant of Edom, And all the Gentiles who are called by My name," Says the LORD who does this thing.
Amos 9:12 · NKJV
And here's the Septuagint:
"In that day I will raise up the tabernacle of David that is fallen, and will rebuild the ruins of it, and will set up the parts thereof that have been broken down, and will build it up as in the ancient days: that the remnant of men, and all the Gentiles upon whom my name is called, may earnestly seek me, saith the Lord who does all these things."
Amos 9:11–12 · Septuagint, tr. Brenton
James quotes the Septuagint. "That the rest of mankind may seek the Lord" is the Greek reading. The Hebrew talks about possessing "the remnant of Edom." And this isn't some passing reference. It's the text the Church's first council used to decide that the Gentiles should be received. The Church's very first ruling on a disputed question was made from the Septuagint's Amos.
St Irenaeus of Lyons: the apostles and the Septuagint
"But not as some allege, among those now presuming to expound the Scripture, [thus:] 'Behold, a young woman shall conceive, and bring forth a son,' as Theodotion the Ephesian has interpreted, and Aquila of Pontus, both Jewish proselytes."
Against Heresies III.21.1
In Irenaeus's own day, people were making new Jewish translations of the Old Testament into Greek, and in Isaiah 7:14 they put "a young woman" where the Septuagint has "a virgin." That's the exact verse Matthew quotes about the birth of Christ (Matthew 1:23). Irenaeus defends the Septuagint by name, and he tells you whose Old Testament it was: "For Peter, and John, and Matthew, and Paul, and the rest successively, as well as their followers, did set forth all prophetical [announcements], just as the interpretation of the elders contains them." The "elders" are the translators of the Septuagint. The apostles preached the prophets the way the Septuagint gives them. And the men who made new translations to get around those prophecies? Irenaeus calls them "impudent and presumptuous."
St Cyril of Jerusalem: learn from the Church
"Learn also diligently, and from the Church, what are the books of the Old Testament, and what those of the New."
Catechetical Lecture 4.33 (c. 350)
St Cyril is teaching people getting ready for baptism in Jerusalem, and he doesn't tell them to figure out for themselves which books belong. He tells them where to get the answer: from the Church. That's this session's question, answered in one sentence.
So the question has an answer, and the answer is what the apostles actually did. The Church received the Old Testament the way the apostles read it, in the Greek Scriptures the Jews of the dispersion had used before Christ came. Not in the form that rabbis who didn't accept Him fixed later on.
The list no verse contains
Open any Bible to the table of contents and ask: where did this list come from? Not from any book on it. No Gospel lists the other Gospels. No epistle lists the epistles. Westminster's first chapter lists sixty-six books and says they're "given by inspiration of God" (1.2). But it doesn't give you a verse the list comes from, because there isn't one. The list is something the Church knew and handed down.
And you can actually watch it get handed down. In AD 367, three centuries after Christ, St Athanasius, bishop of Alexandria, wrote his yearly Paschal letter to the churches of Egypt. Some people, he says, had been mixing books "called apocryphal" in with the divinely inspired Scripture. So he writes out the list.
St Athanasius of Alexandria: "handed down, and accredited"
"…it seemed good to me also, having been urged thereto by true brethren, and having learned from the beginning, to set before you the books included in the Canon, and handed down, and accredited as Divine; to the end that any one who has fallen into error may condemn those who have led him astray."
Letter 39 (AD 367), section 3
Look at his words: included in the Canon, and handed down, and accredited. Athanasius doesn't get the list out of Scripture. He writes down what was handed down to him. And he borrows Luke's own opening words to do it: "Forasmuch as some have taken in hand."
Then he gives the New Testament, and it's the same twenty-seven books every Christian reads today:
These are, the four Gospels, according to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. Afterwards, the Acts of the Apostles and Epistles (called Catholic), seven, viz. of James, one; of Peter, two; of John, three; after these, one of Jude. In addition, there are fourteen Epistles of Paul… And besides, the Revelation of John.St Athanasius, Letter 39, section 5
Exactly these twenty-seven books, named by a bishop in a letter to his people, more than three hundred years after the Resurrection. That's the Bible's own history: the Church existed, preached, worshipped and got persecuted for three centuries before a bishop could hand his people a list of the New Testament books and say, these and no others.
St Augustine of Hippo: moved by the authority of the Church
"For my part, I should not believe the gospel except as moved by the authority of the Catholic Church."
Against the Epistle of Manichæus Called Fundamental 5.6 (AD 397)
Augustine was answering a follower of Mani. Mani called himself "an apostle of Jesus Christ" and wanted people to believe him on the strength of the Gospel. Augustine's answer: the Church whose authority he took the Gospel on is the same Church telling him not to believe Mani. "So when those on whose authority I have consented to believe in the gospel tell me not to believe in Manichæus, how can I but consent?"
Going deeper: Athanasius's whole list
For the Old Testament, Athanasius counts twenty-two books: "as I have heard, it is handed down that this is the number of the letters among the Hebrews," and he counts Jeremiah "with Baruch, Lamentations, and the epistle" as one book. Then he adds a third group: "there are other books besides these not indeed included in the Canon, but appointed by the Fathers to be read by those who newly join us, and who wish for instruction in the word of godliness. The Wisdom of Solomon, and the Wisdom of Sirach, and Esther, and Judith, and Tobit, and that which is called the Teaching of the Apostles, and the Shepherd" (sections 4 and 7).
So in AD 367 the lines were still being drawn: books in the Canon, books the Fathers appointed for reading, and apocryphal books to turn down. And bishops were the ones drawing them, from what had been "handed down," for the good of the flock.
And not every Father drew them in the same place. St Cyril of Jerusalem, teaching in the years before Athanasius's letter, gave his catechumens his own list. It had a twenty-two-book Old Testament that includes Esther (Athanasius's didn't), and a New Testament without the Revelation of John (Catechetical Lecture 4.35–36). Two holy bishops, in two great sees, with two lists.
That's how the Church works, and St Vincent of Lérins gives you the rule. The faith isn't settled by one Father's opinion, no matter how holy he is. It's settled by what has been "held, written, taught, not by one or two of these only, but by all, equally, with one consent, openly, frequently, persistently" (Commonitory 3.8). And when a question needs it, it's settled by the Church in council. A single Father is a witness to the Church's mind, not a replacement for it.
That's how the Church settled these books. The Synod of Jerusalem in 1672 laid out her judgment on the books Athanasius put in the "to be read" group: the Wisdom of Solomon, Judith, Tobit, Susanna, Bel and the Dragon, the Maccabees and Sirach are "genuine parts of Scripture," "for ancient custom, or rather the Catholic Church, which has delivered to us as genuine the Sacred Gospels and the other Books of Scripture, has undoubtedly delivered these also as parts of Scripture, and the denial of these is the rejection of those." The Synod is upfront about the history, "not always have all of these been considered on the same level as the others," and then gives the answer: "these also have been counted and reckoned with the rest of Scripture, both by Synods and by many of the most ancient and eminent Theologians of the Catholic Church" (Confession of Dositheus, Question 3).
No verse of Scripture drew any of these lines. No single Father drew them either. The Church did. And the same Church that handed down the Gospels handed down the rest.
The Scriptures Timothy knew from childhood
The passage people quote most for sola scriptura belongs right here, because it's about which Scriptures Timothy had.
14 But you must continue in the things which you have learned and been assured of, knowing from whom you have learned them, 15 and that from childhood you have known the Holy Scriptures, which are able to make you wise for salvation through faith which is in Christ Jesus. 16 All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, 17 that the man of God may be complete, thoroughly equipped for every good work.2 Timothy 3:14–17
Read the whole sentence. Verse 14 comes first: Timothy is supposed to continue in what he learned, "knowing from whom" he learned it. That's from Paul, by word, "among many witnesses" (2 Timothy 2:2). Then verse 15: the Scriptures he'd known "from childhood." When Timothy was a kid, not one book of the New Testament existed. The Holy Scriptures he grew up with were the Old Testament.
Fr John Whiteford points out where the other reading takes you. The New Testament "had not yet been written when Timothy was a child," so if this verse set the limits of inspired authority, it would leave out "this passage itself and the entire New Testament." All Scripture is inspired and profitable, and the Church has always said so. What the passage doesn't say is that Scripture is the only thing Timothy was supposed to hold. In the same breath he's told to hold what he learned, and to remember who he learned it from.
Sit with these
- Hebrews 10:5 and Acts 15:17 both go with the Septuagint where it's different from the Hebrew. What does that tell you about which Old Testament the apostles read?
- Irenaeus names translators who changed "virgin" to "young woman." Why would the Church stick with the text the apostles preached from?
- Where in Scripture is the list of the books of Scripture? If it's not in there, where did it come from?
- Athanasius calls the books "handed down, and accredited as Divine." Handed down by whom?
- In 2 Timothy 3:14–15, which Scriptures had Timothy known since he was a kid? And what else was he told to continue in?
Carry this
The apostles read the Septuagint, and the Church got the Old Testament from their hands. The list of books isn't in any book. The Church handed it down. If you're holding a Bible, you're holding something the Church gave you.
Session five
The Pillar and Ground of the Truth
Read these first, in this order
1 Timothy 3:14–16 · Matthew 16:13–19 · Matthew 18:15–18 · Luke 10:16 · John 16:12–15 · Acts 15:1–31 · Acts 16:4–5
Scripture calls the Church "the pillar and ground of the truth." The Church, not the Bible. Christ promised the gates of Hades wouldn't prevail against her, told His apostles "he who hears you hears Me," and sent the Spirit to guide them into all truth. And the first time a fight over Scripture split the Church, it didn't get settled by each reader. It got settled by a council.
14 These things I write to you, though I hope to come to you shortly; 15 but if I am delayed, I write so that you may know how you ought to conduct yourself in the house of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth.1 Timothy 3:14–15
St John Chrysostom: the Church maintains the faith
"'That you may know,' he says, 'how you ought to behave yourself in the house of God, which is the Church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth.' Not like that Jewish house. For it is this that maintains the faith and the preaching of the Word. For the truth is the pillar and the ground of the Church."
Homilies on First Timothy 11
The truth holds up the Church, and the Church holds up the truth in front of the world. Chrysostom keeps going in the same homily: "The Church is the pillar of the world." There's no pillar of truth standing in the world apart from the Church that carries it. It's the Church that "maintains the faith and the preaching of the Word."
St Philaret of Moscow: the sure repository
"All true believers united by the holy tradition of the faith, collectively and successively, by the will of God, compose the Church; and she is the sure repository of holy tradition, or, as St. Paul expresses it, The Church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth."
Longer Catechism, question 18
What Christ promised, and to whom
Read the promises together and notice who they're made to. Not readers of a book that didn't exist yet. The Church and her apostles.
And I also say to you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build My church, and the gates of Hades shall not prevail against it.Matthew 16:18
And if he refuses to hear them, tell it to the church. But if he refuses even to hear the church, let him be to you like a heathen and a tax collector.Matthew 18:17
He who hears you hears Me, he who rejects you rejects Me, and he who rejects Me rejects Him who sent Me.Luke 10:16
However, when He, the Spirit of truth, has come, He will guide you into all truth…John 16:13
Christ founds a Church. He promises it won't be overcome. He makes it the last court of appeal among His disciples: "tell it to the church." And He says whoever hears the ones He sends hears Him. So if the Church had failed, if the faith had been lost and somebody had to dig it back out of a book fifteen centuries later, then the gates of Hades won.
Fr John Whiteford spells out what that means: "If the Church ceased to be, for even one day, then the gates of Hell prevailed against it on that day."
The Second Council of Nicaea (787): the promise kept
"Christ our Lord… having espoused to himself the Holy Catholic Church without spot or defect, promised that he would so preserve her: and gave his word to this effect to his holy disciples when he said: 'Lo! I am with you always, even unto the end of the world,' which promise he made, not only to them, but to us also who should believe in his name through their word."
Decree of the Seventh Ecumenical Council
And the Council follows "the traditions of the Catholic Church (for, as we all know, the Holy Spirit indwells her)." The promise of Matthew 28:20 was made to the Church, and the Church in council says it's been kept.
The first council
Now watch the Church do what Christ said. Read Acts 15 straight through. It's the model for how the Church settles a fight over Scripture.
Some men came down from Judea teaching that Gentile believers had to be circumcised to be saved. They had Scripture on their side, or thought they did: God commanded circumcision to Abraham and his seed "for an everlasting covenant" (Genesis 17:13). Paul and Barnabas argued with them. And then:
Therefore, when Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and dispute with them, they determined that Paul and Barnabas and certain others of them should go up to Jerusalem, to the apostles and elders, about this question.Acts 15:2
It doesn't say "each man searched the Scriptures and followed his conscience." Two apostles, and one of them was Paul, took the question to the Church. "Now the apostles and elders came together to consider this matter" (Acts 15:6). Peter talked about what God had done. Barnabas and Paul told about the signs among the Gentiles. And James gave the judgment, from the Septuagint's Amos, like you saw in Session 4. Then the council wrote to the churches:
For it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us, to lay upon you no greater burden than these necessary things…Acts 15:28
"The Holy Spirit, and us." That's the Spirit guiding the Church into truth, like Christ promised, speaking through the apostles and elders gathered together. And then the decision got carried out to the churches as something to keep: "as they went through the cities, they delivered to them the decrees to keep, which were determined by the apostles and elders at Jerusalem. So the churches were strengthened in the faith" (Acts 16:4–5). Every council of the Church since then has followed this pattern.
Bishops who can be named back to the apostles
So how does anybody know which church holds what the apostles handed down? Irenaeus's answer is simple: count the bishops.
St Irenaeus of Lyons: the succession, name by name
"It is within the power of all, therefore, in every Church, who may wish to see the truth, to contemplate clearly the tradition of the apostles manifested throughout the whole world; and we are in a position to reckon up those who were by the apostles instituted bishops in the Churches, and [to demonstrate] the succession of these men to our own times."
Against Heresies III.3.1
He gives one list as an example. It runs from Linus, who Paul mentions in 2 Timothy 4:21, to "Eleutherius [who] does now, in the twelfth place from the apostles, hold the inheritance of the episcopate. In this order, and by this succession, the ecclesiastical tradition from the apostles, and the preaching of the truth, have come down to us" (III.3.3). And he's talking from his own memory here: Polycarp "was not only instructed by apostles, and conversed with many who had seen Christ, but was also, by apostles in Asia, appointed bishop of the Church in Smyrna, whom I also saw in my early youth" (III.3.4). Irenaeus is one man away from the apostles. That's the chain from 2 Timothy 2:2 with names on it.
St Irenaeus of Lyons: the certain gift of truth
"Wherefore it is incumbent to obey the presbyters who are in the Church — those who, as I have shown, possess the succession from the apostles; those who, together with the succession of the episcopate, have received the certain gift of truth, according to the good pleasure of the Father."
Against Heresies IV.26.2
The chapter heading in the standard English translation says it in one line: "the true exposition of the Scriptures is to be found in the Church alone."
Sit with these
- 1 Timothy 3:15 calls something "the pillar and ground of the truth." What is it?
- In Matthew 18:17, where does a dispute between brothers finally go?
- In Acts 15:2, Paul and Barnabas had the Scriptures and the Spirit. Why did they still go up to Jerusalem?
- Acts 15:28 says "it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us." Who is "us"?
- Irenaeus could name his way back to the apostles in two steps. How many steps back to the apostles can your church name?
Carry this
The Church is the pillar and ground of the truth. From the first council on, fights over Scripture were settled by the Church gathered in the Spirit ("it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us"), through bishops you can name all the way back to the apostles.
Session six
"Do You Understand What You Are Reading?"
Read these first, in this order
Acts 8:26–39 · Luke 24:13–32 · Luke 24:44–45 · 2 Peter 1:19–21 · 2 Peter 3:14–16 · John 6:48–58 · Matthew 26:26–28 · John 20:21–23
Scripture doesn't interpret itself. An Ethiopian official reading Isaiah needed Philip. Two disciples walking with the risen Christ needed Him to open their understanding. Peter warns that the unlearned twist Paul's letters. And the clearest test of all is the sacraments, where Christ's plainest words are the very ones sola scriptura can't take literally.
30 So Philip ran to him, and heard him reading the prophet Isaiah, and said, "Do you understand what you are reading?" 31 And he said, "How can I, unless someone guides me?" And he asked Philip to come up and sit with him.Acts 8:30–31
Here's a devout man, headed home from worship in Jerusalem, reading Isaiah 53. That's the clearest prophecy of Christ in the whole Old Testament. He's got the text right in front of him, and he can't tell who the prophet is talking about (Acts 8:34). God doesn't answer him by making the text clearer. He sends a deacon of the Church to explain it. And the explanation ends in baptism (Acts 8:36–38).
And He opened their understanding, that they might comprehend the Scriptures.Luke 24:45
The disciples on the road to Emmaus had the Scriptures, and they had Christ Himself walking right next to them, and they still didn't get it until He opened their minds. And then they knew Him "in the breaking of bread" (Luke 24:35).
20 knowing this first, that no prophecy of Scripture is of any private interpretation, 21 for prophecy never came by the will of man, but holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy Spirit.2 Peter 1:20–21
…as also our beloved brother Paul, according to the wisdom given to him, has written to you, as also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things, in which are some things hard to understand, which untaught and unstable people twist to their own destruction, as they do also the rest of the Scriptures.2 Peter 3:15–16
Think about that. An apostle, writing Scripture, says other Scripture is hard to understand and can be twisted to destruction. That's the opposite of Westminster's confidence that the necessary things are plain to anyone "in a due use of the ordinary means" (1.7).
The Synod of Jerusalem (1672): are the Scriptures plain to all who read them?
"If the Divine Scriptures were plain to all Christians that read them, the Lord would not have commanded such as desired to obtain salvation to search them; and Paul would have said without reason that God had placed the gift of teaching in the Church; and Peter would not have said of the Epistles of Paul that they contained some things hard to be understood."
Confession of Dositheus, Question 2, tr. Robertson, adapted by D. Bratcher
The Synod answers from the verse you just read. The Scriptures "are very profound, and their sense lofty," and their meaning is found by a sense "agreeable to all Scripture, and to its author the Holy Spirit."
Fr Seraphim Rose, lecturing in 1979, says the same thing his own way: Scripture has to be read "in the whole teaching of Christ as handed down in His Church." He quotes St Symeon the New Theologian, who compares the meaning of Scripture to what's inside a locked trunk: "what is concealed in the divine Scriptures cannot be revealed by the Scriptures themselves."
The test case: the sacraments
If Scripture plainly interprets itself, then the plainest words should be the easiest ones to agree on, right? So take the plainest words Christ ever said about the Eucharist.
Then Jesus said to them, "Most assuredly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, you have no life in you."John 6:53
And as they were eating, Jesus took bread, blessed and broke it, and gave it to the disciples and said, "Take, eat; this is My body."Matthew 26:26
"If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained."John 20:23
Fr Seraphim Rose tells about some Protestants who assured him they read the Bible "absolutely literally." He asked them about John 6:53, and "the first thing they said was, 'Well, that is not literal.'" Fr John Whiteford sees the same thing with John 20:23 and Matthew 26:26: when the text teaches something a reader doesn't already believe, "all of a sudden the Bible doesn't say what it means any more."
This is where "Scripture interprets Scripture" falls apart. Christ says "this is My body." Is that plain speech or a figure of speech? That's exactly what the text alone can't settle, and the readers who said it could have been split over it ever since. For the Church it's not a puzzle, because she's been doing what He said, the way the apostles handed it down, since the upper room. St Philaret said it back in Session 1: tradition is necessary "for the right ministration of the sacraments."
The rule: the Church's reading
St Vincent of Lérins: as many interpretations as interpreters
"But here some one perhaps will ask, Since the canon of Scripture is complete, and sufficient of itself for everything, and more than sufficient, what need is there to join with it the authority of the Church's interpretation? For this reason — because, owing to the depth of Holy Scripture, all do not accept it in one and the same sense, but one understands its words in one way, another in another; so that it seems to be capable of as many interpretations as there are interpreters… Therefore, it is very necessary, on account of so great intricacies of such various error, that the rule for the right understanding of the prophets and apostles should be framed in accordance with the standard of Ecclesiastical and Catholic interpretation."
Commonitory 2.5
And here's his rule for finding that interpretation: "we hold that faith which has been believed everywhere, always, by all" (2.6). Not what one reader thinks is plain, but what the whole Church, in every age, has read there.
Tertullian: first ask whose the Scriptures are
"…the natural order of things would require that this point should be first proposed, which is now the only one which we must discuss: 'With whom lies that very faith to which the Scriptures belong. From what and through whom, and when, and to whom, has been handed down that rule, by which men become Christians?' For wherever it shall be manifest that the true Christian rule and faith shall be, there will likewise be the true Scriptures and expositions thereof, and all the Christian traditions."
The Prescription Against Heretics 19
Before you argue about what a verse means, you have to ask whose book it is. The Scriptures belong to the Church that received and handed on the faith they were written in. Find that Church, Tertullian says, and that's where you'll find the true Scriptures, the true explanation of them, and the traditions that go with them.
So how should you read, inside the Church? Fr Seraphim puts it like this: "When we read the Scriptures we must think to ourselves: 'I understand a little, my fathers have taught me, I've read commentaries and heard sermons in church, and my understanding is in accordance with what I've been taught by Church Tradition; but still, I don't trust entirely that I know what it means.'"
Sit with these
- The Ethiopian had Isaiah 53 right in front of him. What was he missing, and how did God give it to him?
- 2 Peter 3:16 says some things in Paul are "hard to understand." Who twists them, and what happens to them?
- Read John 6:53 and Matthew 26:26. What would you have to believe to call these words plain?
- Vincent says Scripture seems to have "as many interpretations as there are interpreters." Do the last five hundred years prove him right?
- Tertullian says the first question is "with whom lies that very faith to which the Scriptures belong." Why does that question have to come first?
Carry this
"How can I, unless someone guides me?" Scripture doesn't interpret itself. It gets read right inside the Church it belongs to. And nowhere is that clearer than at the altar, where Christ said "this is My body," and the Church has been doing what He said ever since.
Session seven
When Every Reader Decides
Read these first, in this order
Matthew 7:15–20 · Galatians 1:6–9 · 1 Corinthians 1:10–13 · 2 Timothy 4:3–4 · 1 Timothy 6:20–21 · Jude 3–4 · John 17:20–23
"You will know them by their fruits." Five hundred years of every reader deciding for himself has produced tens of thousands of separate churches. And over and over, you get a founder who read the Bible for himself, found something in it nobody before him had found, and started his own church.
Division without end
Christ prayed "that they all may be one" (John 17:21). Paul begged the Corinthians "that there be no divisions among you," and he asked them, "Is Christ divided?" (1 Corinthians 1:10, 13).
Back in the 1990s, Fr John Whiteford was already counting "some twenty thousand plus differing Protestant groups… with only the one constant trait of each group claiming that it rightly understands the Bible." The World Christian Encyclopedia (Oxford University Press, 2001) counts over 33,000 Christian denominations. Every one of them reads the same Bible.
Fr John Whiteford grew up among them, and he describes it from the inside. Baptists find "Eternal Security" clearly taught. Methodists find the opposite just as clear, "and so Methodists and Baptists throw verses of the Bible back and forth at each other, each wondering why the other can't 'see' what seems very 'clear' to them." That's Westminster 1.9 at work, the "other places that speak more clearly." Each reader's clear passages decide his unclear ones, and every reader's clear passages are different.
The pattern is old
The Church has seen all this before, and she named it. Back in the second century, Irenaeus described men who claimed they'd found the truth in the Scriptures by their own light:
St Irenaeus of Lyons: "not ashamed to preach himself"
"…so that, according to their idea, the truth properly resides at one time in Valentinus, at another in Marcion, at another in Cerinthus, then afterwards in Basilides, or has even been indifferently in any other opponent, who could speak nothing pertaining to salvation. For every one of these men, being altogether of a perverse disposition, depraving the system of truth, is not ashamed to preach himself."
Against Heresies III.2.1
And when the Church answered them with the tradition the succession of presbyters had kept, "they object to tradition, saying that they themselves are wiser not merely than the presbyters, but even than the apostles, because they have discovered the unadulterated truth" (III.2.2).
Three centuries later, Vincent of Lérins listed the men who each read the same Scripture his own way: "Novatian expounds it one way, Sabellius another, Donatus another, Arius, Eunomius, Macedonius, another… lastly, Nestorius another" (Commonitory 2.5). Then he gave the mark you could know every one of them by:
St Vincent of Lérins: a definite name, place and time
"In truth, what heresy ever burst forth save under a definite name, at a definite place, at a definite time? Who ever originated a heresy that did not first dissever himself from the consentient agreement of the universality and antiquity of the Catholic Church?"
Commonitory 24.62
And here's what the faithful get instead: "What is 'The deposit'? That which has been entrusted to you, not that which you have yourself devised: a matter not of wit, but of learning; not of private adoption, but of public tradition; a matter brought to you, not put forth by you, wherein you are bound to be not an author but a keeper, not a teacher but a disciple, not a leader but a follower" (22.53).
And in 787, like you saw in Session 1, the Seventh Ecumenical Council received a confession that anathematized the claim that you only have to follow what the Old and New Testaments "evidently" teach. It called that the argument of Arius, Nestorius, Eutyches and Dioscorus.
Three founders, in their own words
Now take Vincent's test (a definite name, a definite place, a definite time) and apply it to three movements that have shaped millions of lives in the last two hundred years. Each one started with a man reading the Bible for himself.
| Founder | Where and when | What began it, in his own words |
|---|---|---|
| Joseph Smith the Latter-day Saints | Western New York, 1820 (his account written 1838) | "The teachers of religion of the different sects understood the same passages of scripture so differently as to destroy all confidence in settling the question by an appeal to the Bible." |
| John Nelson Darby dispensationalism; the Brethren | Dublin, 1827–28 | "In my retreat, the 32nd chapter of Isaiah taught me clearly, on God's behalf, that there was still an economy to come." "I saw an evident change of dispensation in that chapter." |
| Charles Taze Russell the Bible Students, from whom came the Jehovah's Witnesses | The Watch Tower, September 15, 1910 | "…if he then lays them aside and ignores them and goes to the Bible alone, though he has understood his Bible for ten years, our experience shows that within two years he goes into darkness." |
Joseph Smith grew up in the middle of the revivals in western New York. He describes "the confusion and strife among the different denominations," so great "that it was impossible for a person young as I was… to come to any certain conclusion who was right and who was wrong" (Joseph Smith—History 1:8). Every one of those denominations appealed to the Bible, and he decided the Bible couldn't settle it: "the teachers of religion of the different sects understood the same passages of scripture so differently as to destroy all confidence in settling the question by an appeal to the Bible" (1:12). He's describing, from the inside, what sola scriptura had produced all around him. And his answer was to go looking for a revelation of his own.
John Nelson Darby was a clergyman in the Church of Ireland who got laid up after falling off his horse in 1827. Alone with his Bible, he writes, "the 32nd chapter of Isaiah taught me clearly, on God's behalf, that there was still an economy to come, of His ordering; a state of things in no way established as yet," and "I saw an evident change of dispensation in that chapter, when the Spirit would be poured out on the Jewish nation, and a king reign in righteousness." Soon after that, he started breaking bread in Dublin with "three other brethren and the wife of one of them," with no clergy. And he helped others study the Bible, "communicating to them the light which God had given me." That reading of Isaiah is where dispensationalism came from: the teaching that God keeps a separate program for the Jewish nation, apart from the Church. Darby doesn't say he got it from the Church. He says he found it on his own, while he was laid up. In 1979, Fr Seraphim Rose pointed to its fruits as examples of people reading their own opinions into the text: "the rapture, for example, or the millennium."
Charles Taze Russell's movement started with Bible study and ended up telling its members that the Bible alone leads into darkness. Russell wrote that people "cannot see the divine plan in studying the Bible by itself," and that whoever set his books aside and went "to the Bible alone… within two years he goes into darkness." But "if he had merely read the Scripture Studies with their references, and had not read a page of the Bible, as such, he would be in the light at the end of the two years" (The Watch Tower, September 15, 1910, as quoted in the Witnesses' own publications).
Look at what these three have in common. Each one started where sola scriptura leaves every reader: one man, alone with the text, deciding for himself what it means. Each one found something in it that nobody in the Church before him had found. And each one, after reading it for himself, then made other people read it his way, through a new prophet, a new "light," a new set of books. The reader who's his own final judge doesn't stay alone. He turns into the founder of the next church.
Fr John Whiteford sees the same thing in two groups that look nothing alike. A Baptist and a Jehovah's Witness arguing over the Bible "simply quote different Scriptures back and forth at each other," because each one has been taught "from a common tradition." So, he says, "the real question is which tradition will we use to interpret the Bible?"
That's the question this study ends on. Everybody who reads the Bible reads it through some tradition. The only choice is which one. Is it a tradition some guy started in the nineteenth century? Or is it the one handed down from the apostles, kept by bishops you can name all the way back to them, confessed in councils, and lived at the same altar for two thousand years?
Sit with these
- Joseph Smith says the sects understood "the same passages of scripture so differently" that the Bible could not settle the question. What had caused the situation he describes?
- Darby found "an evident change of dispensation" in Isaiah 32. Who before him had ever read that there?
- Russell started with Bible study and ended up saying the Bible alone leads into darkness. What happened in between?
- Vincent says every heresy appears "under a definite name, at a definite place, at a definite time." Can you name the place and time your own church's teaching started?
- Fr Whiteford says the real question is "which tradition" you read the Bible through. Which one is yours, and how far back does it go?
Carry this
"You will know them by their fruits." Everybody reads the Bible through some tradition. You either take one that a single man started at a definite place and time, or the one the apostles handed down to the Church that was here before the Bible, and is still here.
A personal word
My 2 Cents
As we read through the Bible, and even through the disputes among our Church Fathers, we see the same struggle again and again: ego and pride.
It begins with a feeling, that "I" know better, without the wisdom to admit that "I" might be wrong. Scripture tells us where that leads: "Pride goes before destruction, and a haughty spirit before a fall" (Proverbs 16:18).
I struggle with both. I pray that God creates in me a humble heart and a wise mind. "Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a steadfast spirit within me" (Psalm 51:10).
I know I am a sinner, and in reality I am not filled with wisdom. So when my own pride starts to lead me astray, I don't have to rely on myself, because I am completely fallible. I have the history of the Church, her Tradition, and the writings of holy men guided by the Holy Spirit to lean on.
"Do not be wise in your own eyes" (Proverbs 3:7). "God resists the proud, but gives grace to the humble" (James 4:6).
Let's pray, daily, for this humility, and for true wisdom, not our wisdom, but wisdom from the LORD. Amen.
The author's own reflection, offered alongside the study rather than as part of its argument.
Reference
The witnesses, by work and section
Every citation is given by work and section so you can check it. If you're going to quote something, verify it first. Quotes from the Fathers float around online in mangled and made-up forms, and getting caught with a fake quote costs you more than the quote was ever worth.
The Fathers of the early Church
| Witness | Work and section | What it supports | Session |
|---|---|---|---|
| St Irenaeus of Lyons (c. 130–202) | Against Heresies III.1.1 | The apostles "at one time proclaim[ed] in public, and, at a later period… handed down to us in the Scriptures" | 2 |
| St Irenaeus | Against Heresies III.2.1–2 | The heretics' "truth" resides in Valentinus, then Marcion, then Cerinthus; each "not ashamed to preach himself" | 7 |
| St Irenaeus | Against Heresies III.3.1, 3–4 | The bishops "instituted by the apostles," reckoned up "to our own times"; Polycarp, "whom I also saw in my early youth" | 5 |
| St Irenaeus | Against Heresies III.4.1–2 | "If the apostles themselves had not left us writings"; nations who believe "without paper or ink" | 2 |
| St Irenaeus | Against Heresies III.21.1–3 | The Septuagint defended; the apostles preached the prophets "just as the interpretation of the elders contains them" | 4 |
| St Irenaeus | Against Heresies IV.26.2 | Obey the presbyters "who possess the succession from the apostles" and "the certain gift of truth" | 5 |
| Tertullian (c. 155–220) | The Prescription Against Heretics 19, 21 | "With whom lies that very faith to which the Scriptures belong"; the apostolic churches taught "both vivâ voce and subsequently by their epistles" | 2, 6 |
| St Cyril of Jerusalem (c. 313–386) | Catechetical Lecture 4.33, 35–36 | "Learn also diligently, and from the Church, what are the books"; his own list, a witness to the Church settling the canon | 4 |
| St Athanasius (c. 296–373) | Letter 39 (AD 367), sections 3–7 | The books "handed down, and accredited as Divine"; the twenty-seven books of the New Testament | 4 |
| St Basil the Great (d. 379) | On the Holy Spirit 27.66 | Written teaching and apostolic tradition "have the same force" | 3 |
| St John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) | Homilies on Second Thessalonians 4 | "Many things also unwritten… It is a tradition, seek no farther" | 3 |
| St John Chrysostom | Homilies on First Timothy 11 | The Church "maintains the faith and the preaching of the Word" | 5 |
| St Augustine of Hippo (354–430) | Against the Epistle of Manichæus 5.6 (AD 397) | "I should not believe the gospel except as moved by the authority of the Catholic Church" | 4 |
| St Vincent of Lérins (Commonitory, AD 434) | Commonitory 2.4–6, 3.8 | Two ways: "the authority of the Divine Law, and then… the Tradition of the Catholic Church"; "as many interpretations as there are interpreters"; "everywhere, always, by all"; "not by one or two… but by all, equally, with one consent" | 1, 4, 6, 7 |
| St Vincent of Lérins | Commonitory 22.53, 24.62 | The deposit: "not of private adoption, but of public tradition"; every heresy "under a definite name, at a definite place, at a definite time" | 7 |
| St John of Damascus (8th c.) | An Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith IV.12, 16 | "Much that has been handed down to us by tradition is unwritten"; 2 Thessalonians 2:15 | 3 |
The Councils and later Fathers
| Witness | Work and section | What it supports | Session |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Second Council of Nicaea (787) | Decree | "We keep unchanged all the ecclesiastical traditions handed down to us, whether in writing or verbally"; Christ's promise to preserve the Church; "the Holy Spirit indwells her" | 3, 5 |
| The Second Council of Nicaea | Session 1: the confession of Basil of Ancyra, received by the Council | Anathema to the claim that "unless we were evidently taught by the Old and New Testaments" the Fathers and Councils need not be followed, called "the arguments of Arius, Nestorius, Eutyches, and Dioscorus" | 1, 7 |
| The Synod of Jerusalem (1672) | Confession of Dositheus, Decree 2; Questions 2–3 | Scripture believed "not otherwise than as the Catholic Church hath interpreted and delivered the same"; the Scriptures not plain to all; the Church that delivered the Gospels delivered the rest | 1, 4, 6 |
| St Philaret of Moscow (19th c.) | Longer Catechism, questions 16–18, 21, 24, 56 | Two channels of revelation; tradition the older; the Church the sure repository; Scripture understood as the Church and the Fathers interpret it | 1, 2, 5 |
Modern Orthodox witnesses
| Witness | Work and section | What it supports | Session |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fr Seraphim Rose (1934–1982) | "How to Read the Holy Scriptures" (1979), Parts 1–3 | Scripture read "in the whole teaching of Christ as handed down in His Church"; John 6:53; the rapture and the millennium | 6, 7 |
| Fr John Whiteford | Sola Scriptura: In the Vanity of Their Minds | Tübingen and Patriarch Jeremias II; paradosis and its source; "which tradition" | 1, 3–7 |
Where to read them
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies III.1 · III.2 · III.3 · III.4 · III.21 · IV.26
- Tertullian, The Prescription Against Heretics, chapters 19 and 21
- Athanasius, Letter 39
- Basil, On the Holy Spirit, chapter 27
- Chrysostom, Homilies on Second Thessalonians 4, on 2 Thessalonians 2:15
- Chrysostom, Homilies on First Timothy 11, on 1 Timothy 3:15
- Vincent of Lérins, Commonitory, chapters 2, 3, 22, 24
- Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lecture 4, sections 33–36
- Augustine, Against the Epistle of Manichæus Called Fundamental, chapter 5
- John of Damascus, An Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith, Book IV, chapters 12 and 16
- The Second Council of Nicaea (787): the Decree, and the confession of Basil of Ancyra in Session 1
- The Confession of Dositheus, Synod of Jerusalem (1672): Decree 2, Questions 2–3; tr. J. N. W. B. Robertson (1899), adapted by D. Bratcher
- St Philaret of Moscow, The Longer Catechism: "On Holy Tradition and Holy Scripture", in Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 2
- Fr Seraphim Rose, "How to Read the Holy Scriptures," Orthodox America: Part 1 · Part 2 · Part 3
- Fr John Whiteford, Sola Scriptura: In the Vanity of Their Minds: the full essay. An expanded version is published by Conciliar Press as Sola Scriptura: An Orthodox Analysis of the Cornerstone of Reformation Theology
Reading them rightly
The Fathers are witnesses to how the Church read Scripture. They're not a second source of revelation. Their weight here comes from how they add up. No one sentence settles the question. What matters is that in Lyons and Carthage, Jerusalem and Alexandria, Caesarea and Constantinople, Hippo and the islands off Gaul and Damascus, in Greek and in Latin, from the second century to the eighth, they all say the same thing. And the Councils after them said it again: the apostles handed the faith down to the Church, by word and by letter. The Scriptures belong to that Church. And they get read right inside her. That agreement is the argument.