Before you begin
How to work through this
Here's the whole study in one sentence: Sunday belongs to Christ, who is really present on the altar in His Body and Blood, and when a church takes Him out of the center, a man fills the empty space, and with no one above that man to hold him accountable, the church slowly becomes his.
Questions this study answers
- What's wrong with celebrity pastors?
- Picking favorite preachers is as old as Corinth, and Paul called it carnal. If the man in front is the draw, something has gone wrong. Session 1 →
- Is worship meant to entertain?
- When church becomes a show, the people become an audience, and an audience is there to be pleased. God warned His prophet about exactly this. Session 3 →
- Is Christ really present in the Eucharist?
- Christ said "this is My body," not "this represents," and the Church has taken Him at His word from the first day. If He's really there, He's the draw. Session 4 →
- Why is liturgical worship so reverent?
- The Liturgy isn't a reminder that God is nearby. It's standing before Him and serving Him, and Scripture commands reverence and discipline in it. Session 5 →
- Who holds an independent church pastor accountable?
- Often no one outside his own board. The Apostles made sure every church had shepherds who answered to someone. Session 6 →
There are six sessions. Each one starts with the passages to read before anything else. Open a Bible and read them first, in order, before you read a word of what I have to say. The key passages are printed here in full, so you never have to take anybody's word for what a text says.
Who this is for. If you grew up in an evangelical or non-denominational church, you know the Sunday this study is talking about. The band warms up the room, the lights go down, the pastor walks out, and for the next forty-five minutes he's the reason you came. Communion, if it happens, is a few minutes at the end, once a month or once a quarter. Nobody in those seats did anything wrong by showing up. Most of us were handed that Sunday and never told there was any other kind. This study is about the other kind, the one the Apostles handed down.
What this study is not saying. It isn't saying preaching is bad, or that a gifted preacher is a problem. St John Chrysostom was called "Golden Mouth" because crowds loved to hear him, and you're going to hear him in almost every session, warning his own crowds about the very thing this study is about. It isn't saying emotion is bad either. The Church has always prized tears of repentance. The question is never whether a man can preach or whether you feel something. The question is who the whole thing is centered on.
The Fathers carry the argument. Every point in this study stands on Scripture and on the Fathers of the early Church, and you'll find their words right where they apply. Here's who you'll hear from: St Clement of Rome, who knew the Apostles and wrote to the church in Corinth before the end of the first century. The Didache, the teaching of the Twelve Apostles, one of the oldest Christian writings outside the New Testament. St Ignatius of Antioch, who was taught by the apostles and died for Christ around AD 107. St Justin Martyr. St Irenaeus of Lyons, who learned the faith from St Polycarp, who learned it from St John. St Cyril of Jerusalem. And St John Chrysostom, the greatest preacher the Church ever had, and the one who fought hardest against preachers becoming the show.
A word about "Catholic"
Whenever the Fathers or this study say "Catholic," the word means what it originally meant: universal, the whole Church throughout the world. It doesn't mean the Roman Catholic Church.
Every Scripture reference on this page is a link. Click any of them and you can read the whole passage.
Go at your own pace. A session takes about forty minutes to read carefully, and longer to really think through. You can mark each one finished as you go, and the page will remember where you left off.
The translation
Scripture is quoted from the New King James Version as it appears in the Orthodox Study Bible. The Orthodox Study Bible's Old Testament follows the Septuagint, so its Psalms are numbered one lower through most of the book. The Fathers are quoted from the standard public-domain English translations, which you can read in full at the links at the end of the study.
The six sessions at a glance
| # | The session | What it establishes |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Who's the Draw? | Picking favorite preachers is as old as Corinth, and Paul called it carnal. Every true servant of God says, "He must increase, but I must decrease." |
| 2 | When the Crowd Makes a God | At Lystra a crowd tried to worship Paul because he was the chief speaker. He tore his clothes. Herod took the praise, and God struck him down. |
| 3 | An Audience, Not a Congregation | God warned about people who treat His word like a lovely song. Chrysostom warned about preachers who live for applause and crowds who come to be entertained. |
| 4 | "This Is My Body" | Christ said "is," four times over, and the Church has taken Him at His word from the first day. When He's really present, He's the draw. |
| 5 | In His Presence, Serving | Scripture commands reverence and discipline in worship. The Liturgy isn't a reminder that God is nearby. It's standing before Him and serving Him. |
| 6 | Answerable to No One | The Apostles made sure every church had shepherds who answered to someone. A church that answers only to itself ends up belonging to the man in front. |
Session one
Who's the Draw?
Read these first, in this order
1 Corinthians 1:10–17 · 1 Corinthians 3:1–7 · John 3:25–30
There's a simple question every Christian should be able to answer about his own church: who's the draw? If the honest answer is the man in front, something has gone wrong, and it went wrong the same way it did in Corinth two thousand years ago.
Start with the first real problem Paul takes on in his first letter to the Corinthians. Before he gets to anything else, before the lawsuits and the immorality and the mess they were making of the Lord's Supper, he goes after this.
10 Now I plead with you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you all speak the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you, but that you be perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment. 11 For it has been declared to me concerning you, my brethren, by those of Chloe's household, that there are contentions among you. 12 Now I say this, that each of you says, "I am of Paul," or "I am of Apollos," or "I am of Cephas," or "I am of Christ." 13 Is Christ divided? Was Paul crucified for you? Or were you baptized in the name of Paul?1 Corinthians 1:10–13
Look at who's on that list. Paul. Apollos, who Acts calls "an eloquent man and mighty in the Scriptures" (Acts 18:24). Cephas, which is Peter. These weren't frauds. They were apostles and true teachers. And the Corinthians had turned them into teams. Everybody had a favorite.
Now look at what Paul does with his own fan club. He doesn't say, "Good, the Paul people have it right." He tears it down first: "Was Paul crucified for you?" The one name in that list that deserves your whole life is the one who was nailed to a cross for you. Everybody else is a servant.
He comes back to it two chapters later, and this time he names it.
4 For when one says, "I am of Paul," and another, "I am of Apollos," are you not carnal? 5 Who then is Paul, and who is Apollos, but ministers through whom you believed, as the Lord gave to each one? 6 I planted, Apollos watered, but God gave the increase. 7 So then neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase.1 Corinthians 3:4–7
"Are you not carnal?" That's Paul's word for following a preacher. Not spiritual. Carnal. Of the flesh. And then the line that ought to be carved over the door of every church: "neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase."
It sounds familiar
You don't have to look hard to find Corinth today. A church gets known by its pastor's name, not by what it believes. People say "I go to Pastor So-and-so's church," and everyone knows what they mean. The sermon series gets a logo. The pastor's face is on the billboard, the website, the podcast. And when he leaves, or falls, half the congregation leaves with him, because he was the reason they came. That's the test. If the man in front walked out tomorrow, would the people still come? If they wouldn't, he was the draw, and Paul already told you what that's called.
Here's how bad it got in Corinth. Around forty years after Paul wrote to them, the same church split again, this time throwing out its own presbyters over a couple of men. The bishop of Rome, St Clement, who had known the Apostles, wrote to them and pointed them straight back to Paul's letter.
St Clement of Rome: worse than the first time
"Take up the epistle of the blessed Apostle Paul. What did he write to you at the time when the gospel first began to be preached? Truly, under the inspiration of the Spirit, he wrote to you concerning himself, and Cephas, and Apollos, because even then parties had been formed among you. But that inclination for one above another entailed less guilt upon you, inasmuch as your partialities were then shown towards apostles, already of high reputation, and towards a man whom they had approved. But now reflect who those are that have perverted you, and lessened the renown of your far-famed brotherly love."
Letter to the Corinthians 47 (c. AD 96)
Read that carefully. Clement says the first time was bad, but at least they were picking between apostles. Now they're following men with no standing at all, and it's worse. "That inclination for one above another" is his name for the whole disease. When it's pointed at an apostle, it's a sin. When it's pointed at a man nobody sent, it tears a church apart.
Earlier in the same letter, Clement gives the cure.
St Clement of Rome: let our praise be in God
"Let our praise be in God, and not of ourselves; for God hates those that commend themselves. Let testimony to our good deeds be borne by others, as it was in the case of our righteous forefathers. Boldness, and arrogance, and audacity belong to those that are accursed of God; but moderation, humility, and meekness to such as are blessed by Him."
Letter to the Corinthians 30
The friend of the bridegroom
Now go to the man Christ called the greatest ever born of women (Matthew 11:11). John the Baptist had crowds. He had disciples. He had a following. And then Jesus started baptizing, and the crowds moved. John's disciples came to him upset about it.
26 And they came to John and said to him, "Rabbi, He who was with you beyond the Jordan, to whom you have testified; behold, He is baptizing, and all are coming to Him!" 27 John answered and said, "A man can receive nothing unless it has been given to him from heaven. 28 You yourselves bear me witness, that I said, 'I am not the Christ,' but, 'I have been sent before Him.' 29 He who has the bride is the bridegroom; but the friend of the bridegroom, who stands and hears him, rejoices greatly because of the bridegroom's voice. Therefore this joy of mine is fulfilled. 30 He must increase, but I must decrease."John 3:26–30
"All are coming to Him!" His disciples said it like it was bad news. John heard it as the best news of his life. The bride, the Church, belongs to the Bridegroom. The best man doesn't try to get the bride to look at him. He stands off to the side and he's happy when she only has eyes for the groom. "Therefore this joy of mine is fulfilled." That's what a real servant of God feels when people stop looking at him and start looking at Christ.
St Ignatius, on his way to be thrown to the lions, put it in one line to the church at Smyrna: "Let not [high] place puff any one up: for that which is worth all is faith and love, to which nothing is to be preferred" (Epistle to the Smyrnaeans 6).
And St John Chrysostom, preaching to his own crowds in Constantinople, who loved to hear him, aimed it straight at men like himself.
St John Chrysostom: to the man with the gift
"Account nothing to be of yourself. Have you utterance and grace of teaching? Do not for this account yourself to have anything more than other men. For this cause especially you ought to be humbled, because you have been vouchsafed more abundant gifts... Why do you think great things of yourself? Because you teach by words? But this is easy, to philosophize in words: teach me by your life: that is the best teaching."
Homily 30 on the Acts of the Apostles
This is the Church's most gifted preacher, and he's telling gifted preachers that the gift is a reason to be more humble, not less. "Teach me by your life." The Church has never judged a teacher by how well he talks.
Sit with these
- Paul, Apollos and Cephas were all true teachers. Why was it still carnal for the Corinthians to pick favorites among them (1 Corinthians 3:3–4)?
- "Was Paul crucified for you?" (1 Corinthians 1:13). What does that question say about who deserves a Christian's loyalty?
- If the man in front of your church walked out tomorrow, would you still come? What does your honest answer tell you?
- St Clement calls the disease "that inclination for one above another." Where have you seen it?
- John the Baptist's joy was "fulfilled" when the crowds left him for Christ (John 3:29). What would a pastor like that look like?
Carry this
"Neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase." The only name that belongs at the center of a church is the one who was crucified for it.
Session two
When the Crowd Makes a God
Read these first, in this order
Acts 14:8–18 · Acts 12:20–23 · Acts 10:25–26 · Revelation 22:8–9
When a crowd tried to worship the Apostles, they tore their clothes and ran into the crowd shouting to stop it. When a crowd shouted that Herod's voice was the voice of a god, he let them, and God struck him dead. Those are the only two ways a man in front of a crowd can answer.
This is the centerpiece of the whole study, so read every word.
8 And in Lystra a certain man without strength in his feet was sitting, a cripple from his mother's womb, who had never walked. 9 This man heard Paul speaking. Paul, observing him intently and seeing that he had faith to be healed, 10 said with a loud voice, "Stand up straight on your feet!" And he leaped and walked. 11 Now when the people saw what Paul had done, they raised their voices, saying in the Lycaonian language, "The gods have come down to us in the likeness of men!" 12 And Barnabas they called Zeus, and Paul, Hermes, because he was the chief speaker. 13 Then the priest of Zeus, whose temple was in front of their city, brought oxen and garlands to the gates, intending to sacrifice with the multitudes. 14 But when the apostles Barnabas and Paul heard this, they tore their clothes and ran in among the multitude, crying out 15 and saying, "Men, why are you doing these things? We also are men with the same nature as you, and preach to you that you should turn from these useless things to the living God, who made the heaven, the earth, the sea, and all things that are in them, 16 who in bygone generations allowed all nations to walk in their own ways. 17 Nevertheless He did not leave Himself without witness, in that He did good, gave us rain from heaven and fruitful seasons, filling our hearts with food and gladness." 18 And with these sayings they could scarcely restrain the multitudes from sacrificing to them.Acts 14:8–18
Walk through it.
Verses 8 to 10: a real miracle. God heals a man who's never walked a day in his life. Nothing fake about it.
Verses 11 and 12: the crowd sees the power and puts it on the men. They decide Barnabas is Zeus, the king of the gods. And look at why they decide Paul is Hermes: "because he was the chief speaker." Hermes was the messenger of the gods, the talker. The man with the microphone got made into a god because he was the one doing the talking. That's the oldest version of the thing this study is about, and Scripture wrote it down for us.
Verse 13: it's not just talk anymore. The priest shows up with oxen and garlands. There's going to be a sacrifice, and the Apostles are the ones being worshiped.
Verses 14 and 15: and here's how you know they were real. They don't smile and wave. They don't say, "Well, God's using this to draw people in." They tear their clothes, the sign of grief and horror in the Bible, and they run into the crowd, shouting, "We also are men with the same nature as you." And then they turn the whole thing toward "the living God, who made the heaven, the earth, the sea."
Verse 18: and even then, they barely stopped it. A crowd that wants a god is hard to talk out of one.
St John Chrysostom preached on this passage, and he saw exactly what it shows about the men.
St John Chrysostom: clean from the lust of glory
"See how on all occasions they are clean from the lust of glory, not only not coveting, but even repudiating it when offered: just as Peter also said, 'Why gaze ye on us, as though by our own power or holiness we had made him to walk?' So these also say the same."
Homily 30 on the Acts of the Apostles
"Here was a new sort of trial, from immoderate zeal, and no small one: but hence also is shown the virtue of the Apostles, (and) how on all occasions they ascribe all to God."
Homily 30 on the Acts of the Apostles
"Clean from the lust of glory." Chrysostom calls the craving for glory what it is, a lust. And notice he calls the crowd's worship a trial, a temptation. The Lystrans weren't being wicked. They were impressed, sincerely, by something that really happened. That's what makes it dangerous. Sincere people with real enthusiasm can build an idol out of a man, and the only thing that stops it is the man refusing to let them.
And in the next homily, he stays on verse 14:
St John Chrysostom: they ran in
"Mark the vehemence with which all this is done by the Apostles: rent their clothes, ran in, cried out, all from strong affection of the soul, revolted by the things that were done."
Homily 31 on the Acts of the Apostles
"Revolted." Being worshiped didn't flatter them. It made them sick. That's the reaction of a man who knows who God is and who he isn't.
The man who took the praise
Now read the opposite answer. Luke puts it just two chapters earlier, like he wants you to compare them.
21 So on a set day Herod, arrayed in royal apparel, sat on his throne and gave an oration to them. 22 And the people kept shouting, "The voice of a god and not of a man!" 23 Then immediately an angel of the Lord struck him, because he did not give glory to God. And he was eaten by worms and died.Acts 12:21–23
Same setup. A man gives a speech. A crowd goes wild. They say his voice is divine. The only difference is what the man does with it. Paul tore his clothes. Herod sat on his throne in his royal robes and soaked it in. And Scripture tells you exactly why he died: "because he did not give glory to God." Not because he murdered James, which he did (Acts 12:2). Not because he jailed Peter. Because he let the crowd give him the glory that belongs to God.
Even an angel won't take it
Look at how consistent Scripture is about this. When Cornelius, a Roman centurion, fell at Peter's feet, "Peter lifted him up, saying, 'Stand up; I myself am also a man'" (Acts 10:26). And at the end of the Bible, when St John himself fell down before the angel who showed him the Revelation:
8 Now I, John, saw and heard these things. And when I heard and saw, I fell down to worship before the feet of the angel who showed me these things. 9 Then he said to me, "See that you do not do that. For I am your fellow servant, and of your brethren the prophets, and of those who keep the words of this book. Worship God."Revelation 22:8–9
An angel of God, standing in heaven, wouldn't take it. "I am your fellow servant... Worship God." If an angel won't let the spotlight land on him, what business does a man with a headset mic have taking it?
No oxen required
Nobody's bringing oxen and garlands to church anymore. It doesn't look like that now. It looks like applause when he walks on stage. It looks like his name on the building and his face on the screen. It looks like people who can quote the pastor better than they can quote the Gospels. It looks like a man who can't be questioned, because questioning him feels like questioning God. The garlands changed. The temptation didn't. And the test for the man in front is exactly the same as it was in Lystra: does he tear his clothes, or does he take the garland?
Sit with these
- The Lystrans made Paul into Hermes "because he was the chief speaker" (Acts 14:12). Why is the one who does the talking the easiest one to turn into an idol?
- The miracle at Lystra was real. Why didn't that make the crowd's response right?
- Chrysostom calls the crowd's worship "a new sort of trial, from immoderate zeal." Can sincere, enthusiastic people build an idol without meaning to?
- Herod died "because he did not give glory to God" (Acts 12:23). What's the difference between what Herod did and what Paul did?
- What does taking the garland look like today? What would tearing your clothes look like?
Carry this
"We also are men with the same nature as you." The Apostles tore their clothes at the first sign of worship. Herod took it and died. Every man in front of a crowd is choosing one or the other.
Session three
An Audience, Not a Congregation
Read these first, in this order
Ezekiel 33:30–33 · 2 Timothy 4:1–5 · Isaiah 29:13
When church becomes a show, the people become an audience, and an audience is there to be pleased. God warned His prophet about exactly this, long before anybody had a stage or a sound system.
Read what God told Ezekiel about the people who came to hear him.
30 "As for you, son of man, the children of your people are talking about you beside the walls and in the doors of the houses; and they speak to one another, everyone saying to his brother, 'Please come and hear what the word is that comes from the LORD.' 31 So they come to you as people do, they sit before you as My people, and they hear your words, but they do not do them; for with their mouth they show much love, but their hearts pursue their own gain. 32 Indeed you are to them as a very lovely song of one who has a pleasant voice and can play well on an instrument; for they hear your words, but they do not do them. 33 And when this comes to pass—surely it will come—then they will know that a prophet has been among them."Ezekiel 33:30–33
Everything in this passage is happening right now. People are talking about the preacher around town: "Come hear this guy." They show up. They sit there like God's people. They "show much love." And God says what's really going on: "you are to them as a very lovely song of one who has a pleasant voice and can play well on an instrument." They're enjoying it. It's a good show. And twice, in two verses, God says the same thing: "they hear your words, but they do not do them."
That's the difference between an audience and a congregation. An audience comes to hear something good. A congregation comes to do something, to offer worship to God and be changed by Him. You can fill a building with an audience every week and never make a single disciple.
They'll heap up teachers
Paul saw it coming too, and he told Timothy who would be driving it.
2 Preach the word! Be ready in season and out of season. Convince, rebuke, exhort, with all longsuffering and teaching. 3 For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine, but according to their own desires, because they have itching ears, they will heap up for themselves teachers; 4 and they will turn their ears away from the truth, and be turned aside to fables.2 Timothy 4:2–4
Look who's doing the heaping in verse 3. Not the teachers. The people. "According to their own desires... they will heap up for themselves teachers." When people want to be pleased, they'll find somebody to please them, and if one church won't do it, the next one down the road will. It's supply and demand. That's why this isn't only a pastor problem. The pastor who plays to the crowd and the crowd that shops for a pastor are feeding each other.
St John Chrysostom wrote a whole book about the priesthood, and in it he describes exactly this crowd, in the fourth century.
St John Chrysostom: like critics at a show
"For the public are accustomed to listen not for profit, but for pleasure, sitting like critics of tragedies, and of musical entertainments... A preacher then should have loftiness of mind, far exceeding my own littleness of spirit, that he may correct this disorderly and unprofitable pleasure on the part of the multitude, and be able to lead them over to a more useful way of hearing, that his people may follow and yield to him, and that he may not be led away by their own humors, and this it is not possible to arrive at, except by two means: indifference to their praise, and the power of preaching well."
On the Priesthood, Book V
"Sitting like critics of tragedies, and of musical entertainments." Sixteen hundred years ago, people came to church to rate the performance. And Chrysostom says the preacher's job is to correct that, not feed it, and he can only do it if he doesn't care whether they praise him. "Indifference to their praise." Hold that up next to a church that measures everything by attendance and applause.
Chrysostom against the applause
In Chrysostom's day, crowds clapped and cheered during sermons, like at the theater. He hated it. In one sermon on Acts he stopped and took it on directly, and he was honest about his own weakness while he did it. Read the whole thing slowly.
St John Chrysostom: this has turned the Churches upside down
"Many take a deal of pains to be able to stand up in public, and make a long speech: and if they get applause from the multitude, it is to them as if they gained the very kingdom (of heaven): but if silence follows the close of their speech, it is worse than hell itself, the dejection that falls upon their spirits from the silence! This has turned the Churches upside down, because both you desire not to hear a discourse calculated to lead you to compunction, but one that may delight you from the sound and composition of the words, as though you were listening to singers and minstrels: and we too act a preposterous and pitiable part in being led by your lusts, when we ought to root them out."
Homily 30 on the Acts of the Apostles
"This has turned the Churches upside down." He blames both sides, just like Paul did. The people want to be delighted instead of cut to the heart, and the preachers give it to them "when we ought to root them out."
"Just such is our case, when we idly busy ourselves about beautiful expressions, and the composition and harmony of our sentences, in order that we may please, not profit: (when) we make it our aim to be admired, not to instruct; to delight, not prick to the heart; to be applauded and depart with praise, not to correct men's manners! Believe me, I speak not other than I feel: when as I discourse I hear myself applauded, at the moment indeed I feel it as a man (for why should I not own the truth?): I am delighted, and give way to the pleasurable feeling: but when I get home, and bethink me that those who applauded received no benefit from my discourse, but that whatever benefit they ought to have got, they lost it while applauding and praising, I am in pain, and groan, and weep, and feel as if I had spoken all in vain."
Homily 30 on the Acts of the Apostles
That's the most honest thing a famous preacher ever said. He admits the applause feels good. And then he goes home and weeps, because he knows the people who were clapping didn't get anything out of it. "To be admired, not to instruct; to delight, not prick to the heart." There's the whole difference between a show and a church in one sentence.
"Nothing so becomes a Church as silence and good order. Noise belongs to theatres, and baths, and public processions, and market-places: but where doctrines, and such doctrines, are the subject of teaching, there should be stillness, and quiet, and calm reflection, and a haven of much repose."
Homily 30 on the Acts of the Apostles
Feeling isn't the enemy
None of this means you're supposed to feel nothing in church. "The sacrifices of God are a broken spirit, a broken and a contrite heart" (Psalm 51:17, Psalm 50 in your Orthodox Study Bible). The Church has always prized tears of repentance, and Chrysostom himself wanted sermons "calculated to lead you to compunction," to cut people to the heart.
The line he draws is between two kinds of feeling. One is the fruit of standing before God: sorrow for sin, awe, joy in Him. The other is a product, manufactured with lighting, volume and a key change at the right moment, and it can be produced whether God is being worshiped or not. The first one changes your life. The second one wears off in the parking lot. That's the difference between "to delight" and "to prick to the heart."
God said it through Isaiah, and Christ repeated it to the Pharisees: "these people draw near with their mouths and honor Me with their lips, but have removed their hearts far from Me" (Isaiah 29:13; Matthew 15:8). You can sing every word and mean none of it. A service built to make you feel good can't tell the difference. God can.
Sit with these
- God says the people treated Ezekiel "as a very lovely song" (Ezekiel 33:32). What's the difference between enjoying God's word and doing it?
- In 2 Timothy 4:3, who heaps up the teachers? What does that say about the people in the seats?
- Chrysostom says a preacher can only correct the crowd through "indifference to their praise." Why can't a man who needs applause tell people what they don't want to hear?
- "To delight, not prick to the heart." Which one does your Sunday aim for?
- How can you tell the difference between feeling that comes from standing before God and feeling that's been produced for you?
Carry this
"They hear your words, but they do not do them." An audience comes to be pleased. A congregation comes to worship God and be changed. Only one of them is a church.
Session four
"This Is My Body"
Read these first, in this order
Matthew 26:26–28 · Mark 14:22–24 · Luke 22:19–20 · 1 Corinthians 11:23–26 · John 6:48–69 · 1 Corinthians 10:16–17 · Luke 24:28–35
Christ didn't say "this represents My body." He said "this is." The Church has taken Him at His word from the very first day, and that one word decides what Sunday is for. If He's really there, He's the draw. If He isn't, somebody else will be.
This session is the root of everything else in this study. So start where the Lord's Supper started, at the table on the night He was betrayed. It's told four times in the New Testament. Read all four.
26 And as they were eating, Jesus took bread, blessed and broke it, and gave it to the disciples and said, "Take, eat; this is My body." 27 Then He took the cup, and gave thanks, and gave it to them, saying, "Drink from it, all of you. 28 For this is My blood of the new covenant, which is shed for many for the remission of sins."Matthew 26:26–28
22 And as they were eating, Jesus took bread, blessed and broke it, and gave it to them and said, "Take, eat; this is My body." 23 Then He took the cup, and when He had given thanks He gave it to them, and they all drank from it. 24 And He said to them, "This is My blood of the new covenant, which is shed for many."Mark 14:22–24
19 And He took bread, gave thanks and broke it, and gave it to them, saying, "This is My body which is given for you; do this in remembrance of Me." 20 Likewise He also took the cup after supper, saying, "This cup is the new covenant in My blood, which is shed for you."Luke 22:19–20
23 For I received from the Lord that which I also delivered to you: that the Lord Jesus on the same night in which He was betrayed took bread; 24 and when He had given thanks, He broke it and said, "Take, eat; this is My body which is broken for you; do this in remembrance of Me." 25 In the same manner He also took the cup after supper, saying, "This cup is the new covenant in My blood. This do, as often as you drink it, in remembrance of Me." 26 For as often as you eat this bread and drink this cup, you proclaim the Lord's death till He comes.1 Corinthians 11:23–26
| Account | Over the bread | Over the cup |
|---|---|---|
| Matthew 26 | "This is My body" | "This is My blood of the new covenant" |
| Mark 14 | "This is My body" | "This is My blood of the new covenant" |
| Luke 22 | "This is My body which is given for you" | "This cup is the new covenant in My blood" |
| 1 Corinthians 11 | "This is My body which is broken for you" | "This cup is the new covenant in My blood" |
Four accounts. Three Gospel writers and an Apostle who says he "received from the Lord" what he's handing on. Not one of them says "represents," "stands for," or "is a symbol of." Christ was the Word of God. He knew how to say "this is like My body" if that's what He meant. He'd been teaching in parables for three years. At this table, He didn't use one.
The chapter where people walked out
A year earlier, Christ had already told them what was coming. Read John 6 all the way through, including the part that's hard.
51 I am the living bread which came down from heaven. If anyone eats of this bread, he will live forever; and the bread that I shall give is My flesh, which I shall give for the life of the world." 52 The Jews therefore quarreled among themselves, saying, "How can this Man give us His flesh to eat?" 53 Then Jesus said to them, "Most assuredly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, you have no life in you. 54 Whoever eats My flesh and drinks My blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day. 55 For My flesh is food indeed, and My blood is drink indeed. 56 He who eats My flesh and drinks My blood abides in Me, and I in him. 57 As the living Father sent Me, and I live because of the Father, so he who feeds on Me will live because of Me. 58 This is the bread which came down from heaven—not as your fathers ate the manna, and are dead. He who eats this bread will live forever."John 6:51–58
Watch what happens in verse 52. The crowd takes Him literally: "How can this Man give us His flesh to eat?" Every other time in the Gospels that people took Him too literally, He corrected them. When Nicodemus thought "born again" meant going back into his mother's womb, Christ explained it (John 3:4–5). When the disciples thought "leaven" meant bread, He explained it (Matthew 16:6–12). Here, when they take Him literally, He doesn't soften a thing. He doubles down, and He swears to it: "Most assuredly, I say to you." Then four more times: eat My flesh, drink My blood. And verse 55 takes away every way out: "My flesh is food indeed, and My blood is drink indeed." Truly food. Truly drink.
60 Therefore many of His disciples, when they heard this, said, "This is a hard saying; who can understand it?" 61 When Jesus knew in Himself that His disciples complained about this, He said to them, "Does this offend you? 62 What then if you should see the Son of Man ascend where He was before? 63 It is the Spirit who gives life; the flesh profits nothing. The words that I speak to you are spirit, and they are life. 64 But there are some of you who do not believe." For Jesus knew from the beginning who they were who did not believe, and who would betray Him. 65 And He said, "Therefore I have said to you that no one can come to Me unless it has been granted to him by My Father." 66 From that time many of His disciples went back and walked with Him no more. 67 Then Jesus said to the twelve, "Do you also want to go away?" 68 But Simon Peter answered Him, "Lord, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. 69 Also we have come to believe and know that You are the Christ, the Son of the living God."John 6:60–69
Verse 60: it's not just the crowd anymore. His own disciples say it's a hard saying. If He'd been talking in a simple symbol, nothing about it would've been hard.
Verse 63 is the verse people point to when they want this to be only a symbol: "the flesh profits nothing." Read what He actually says. He doesn't say "My flesh profits nothing." Twelve verses earlier He said His flesh is what He'll give "for the life of the world" (verse 51). His flesh profits the whole world. What profits nothing is "the flesh," the natural, fleshly way of hearing Him that was making them stumble. And verse 64 tells you what the real problem was: "there are some of you who do not believe." The issue at the end of John 6 isn't whether He meant it. It's whether they believed Him.
Verse 66: "many of His disciples went back and walked with Him no more." This is the only place in the Gospels where disciples walk away from Christ over a teaching. And He lets them go. He doesn't call after them, "Wait, I only meant it as a symbol." He turns to the Twelve and asks if they're leaving too. And Peter gives the answer every Orthodox Christian gives at the chalice: "Lord, to whom shall we go?"
Paul, writing to the same Corinthians who had turned their preachers into teams, spells it out plainly.
16 The cup of blessing which we bless, is it not the communion of the blood of Christ? The bread which we break, is it not the communion of the body of Christ? 17 For we, though many, are one bread and one body; for we all partake of that one bread.1 Corinthians 10:16–17
Communion in the blood of Christ. Communion in the body of Christ. Paul asks it as a question because he expects every Christian to already know the answer is yes.
"In remembrance of Me"
If you were raised on the memorial view, the verse you were given was Luke 22:19: "do this in remembrance of Me." But that line is in the middle of the same sentence as "This is My body." Christ said both at once, and the Church has always held both at once. You remember Him by doing what He said, and what He said is that it's His Body. Here's the earliest description of Christian worship outside the New Testament, written to the Roman emperor around AD 155. Watch how Justin quotes the words of institution.
St Justin Martyr: not common bread
"And this food is called among us Eucharistia [the Eucharist], of which no one is allowed to partake but the man who believes that the things which we teach are true, and who has been washed with the washing that is for the remission of sins, and unto regeneration, and who is so living as Christ has enjoined. For not as common bread and common drink do we receive these; but in like manner as Jesus Christ our Saviour, having been made flesh by the Word of God, had both flesh and blood for our salvation, so likewise have we been taught that the food which is blessed by the prayer of His word, and from which our blood and flesh by transmutation are nourished, is the flesh and blood of that Jesus who was made flesh. For the apostles, in the memoirs composed by them, which are called Gospels, have thus delivered unto us what was enjoined upon them; that Jesus took bread, and when He had given thanks, said, 'This do ye in remembrance of Me, this is My body;' and that, after the same manner, having taken the cup and given thanks, He said, 'This is My blood.'"
First Apology 66 (c. AD 155)
"This do ye in remembrance of Me, this is My body." Justin puts them right next to each other, and he doesn't see any tension at all. And he says plainly what the Church received: "not as common bread and common drink," but "the flesh and blood of that Jesus who was made flesh." This is a man who was martyred for Christ about ten years later. He isn't guessing at what the Church believed. He's telling a pagan emperor what Christians do every Sunday.
Fifty years before Justin, a bishop who had been taught by the Apostles was already warning about people who denied it.
St Ignatius of Antioch: the flesh of our Saviour
"They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer, because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins, and which the Father, of His goodness, raised up again. Those, therefore, who speak against this gift of God, incur death in the midst of their disputes. But it were better for them to treat it with respect, that they also might rise again."
Epistle to the Smyrnaeans 7 (c. AD 107)
Around AD 107, writing on his way to martyrdom, St Ignatius points to the people who "confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ." Denying it wasn't a respectable alternate view in his Church. It was the mark of the people who had left.
And in the fourth century, St Cyril of Jerusalem was teaching new Christians, the week after their baptism, what they had just received.
St Cyril of Jerusalem: not bare elements
"Even of itself the teaching of the Blessed Paul is sufficient to give you a full assurance concerning those Divine Mysteries, of which having been deemed worthy, you have become of the same body and blood with Christ."
Catechetical Lecture 22 (Mystagogical Lecture 4), 1
"Consider therefore the Bread and the Wine not as bare elements, for they are, according to the Lord's declaration, the Body and Blood of Christ; for even though sense suggests this to you, yet let faith establish you. Judge not the matter from the taste, but from faith be fully assured without misgiving, that the Body and Blood of Christ have been vouchsafed to you."
Catechetical Lecture 22 (Mystagogical Lecture 4), 6
"Not as bare elements." "Judge not the matter from the taste." Cyril knows it still looks and tastes like bread and wine. He tells them to believe Christ's word over their tongue. That's exactly what Peter did in John 6.
And when the risen Christ walked with two disciples to Emmaus, they didn't recognize Him on the road, even while He explained the Scriptures to them. "He took bread, blessed and broke it, and gave it to them. Then their eyes were opened and they knew Him" (Luke 24:30–31). They told the Apostles "how He was known to them in the breaking of bread" (Luke 24:35). The sermon on the road set their hearts burning. But they knew Him at the table.
Two kinds of Sunday
Now you can see why this matters so much for this study. Put the two Sundays side by side.
| The message-based service | The Divine Liturgy | |
|---|---|---|
| At the center | A stage, a pulpit, a screen | The altar |
| The main event | The sermon | The Eucharist |
| Communion | A remembrance of Someone absent, often monthly or quarterly | The Body and Blood of Christ, every Lord's Day |
| The man in front | Faces the people and performs for them | Faces the altar with the people and serves |
| Why you came | To hear him | To receive Him |
Not every Protestant church holds the memorial view. Lutherans, for one, still confess a real presence. But in most evangelical and non-denominational churches, the bread is a symbol and the sermon is the service. And here's the thing nobody says out loud: when Christ isn't believed to be really present, the center of Sunday is empty. Something has to fill it. The sermon fills it, so the man preaching fills it. The cult of personality isn't only bad behavior by a few pastors. It's what naturally grows in the space left when the altar is taken out.
Where the Church believes Christ is truly on the altar, nobody's looking at the priest. They came for Him.
Sit with these
- In four accounts, Christ says "is" over the bread and the cup. Why do you think He didn't use a parable at that table, when He used so many elsewhere?
- In John 6:52–53, the crowd takes Him literally, and He answers with "Most assuredly." Why would He do that if they'd misunderstood Him?
- Read John 6:51 and 6:63 together. Is Christ saying His own flesh profits nothing?
- Justin quotes "This do ye in remembrance of Me, this is My body" in one breath. Can remembrance and real presence go together?
- If Christ is really present on the altar, who is the draw on Sunday? And if He isn't, who fills the space?
Carry this
"My flesh is food indeed, and My blood is drink indeed." When Christ is at the center, He's the reason you come. Take Him out, and a man will take His place.
Session five
In His Presence, Serving
Read these first, in this order
1 Corinthians 11:27–34 · Hebrews 12:18–29 · Leviticus 10:1–3 · Isaiah 6:1–5 · Acts 13:1–3 · Acts 2:42–43 · Malachi 1:11
The Liturgy isn't a warm reminder that God is somewhere nearby. It's standing in front of Him and serving Him. Scripture treats that as serious business, commands reverence and discipline in it, and the Church always has.
There's a big difference between saying "God is with us" and saying "we are standing before God." The first one can be said casually, as a nice thought on the way into a concert. The second one changes how you walk in the door. Scripture speaks the second way. Start with what Paul told the Corinthians right after he gave them the words of institution.
27 Therefore whoever eats this bread or drinks this cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord. 28 But let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of the bread and drink of the cup. 29 For he who eats and drinks in an unworthy manner eats and drinks judgment to himself, not discerning the Lord's body. 30 For this reason many are weak and sick among you, and many sleep. 31 For if we would judge ourselves, we would not be judged. 32 But when we are judged, we are chastened by the Lord, that we may not be condemned with the world.1 Corinthians 11:27–32
Read verse 27 again. Taking it unworthily makes you "guilty of the body and blood of the Lord." You can't be guilty of the body and blood of a symbol. Nobody is guilty of murder for tearing up a photograph. Paul talks this way because what's on the table is what Christ said it is. Verse 29: the sin is "not discerning the Lord's body," not recognizing what's in front of you. And verse 30 is as blunt as the Bible gets: people in Corinth got sick, and some of them died, over how they received it. "Many sleep." That's how seriously God takes His table.
You have come
The letter to the Hebrews tells you where Christians actually are when they gather to worship.
22 But you have come to Mount Zion and to the city of the living God, the heavenly Jerusalem, to an innumerable company of angels, 23 to the general assembly and church of the firstborn who are registered in heaven, to God the Judge of all, to the spirits of just men made perfect, 24 to Jesus the Mediator of the new covenant, and to the blood of sprinkling that speaks better things than that of Abel.Hebrews 12:22–24
28 Therefore, since we are receiving a kingdom which cannot be shaken, let us have grace, by which we may serve God acceptably with reverence and godly fear. 29 For our God is a consuming fire.Hebrews 12:28–29
Not "you will come someday." "You have come." Present tense. When the Church worships, it stands with the angels, the saints, "God the Judge of all," and "Jesus the Mediator." That's the room you're in. And the very next thing the writer says is how to behave in it: "serve God acceptably with reverence and godly fear. For our God is a consuming fire." That isn't Old Testament. It's the New Covenant, telling Christians how to worship.
The word "liturgy"
Look at how Acts describes the church in Antioch gathered before God:
As they ministered to the Lord and fasted, the Holy Spirit said, "Now separate to Me Barnabas and Saul for the work to which I have called them."Acts 13:2
"Ministered to the Lord." The Greek verb there is leitourgeō, and it's where the word liturgy comes from. The first Christians didn't gather to be ministered to. They gathered to minister to the Lord, to offer Him service. And while they were doing it, the Holy Spirit spoke. The whole direction runs toward God. That's what "Liturgy" means: the service offered to God by His people, together.
And the first church in Jerusalem? "They continued steadfastly in the apostles' doctrine and fellowship, in the breaking of bread, and in prayers. Then fear came upon every soul" (Acts 2:42–43). Steadfast. Fear. Not a word about a show.
Strange fire
God has always cared how He's worshiped, and not just that He is. Here's what happened on the very first day of priestly worship in the Tabernacle.
1 Then Nadab and Abihu, the sons of Aaron, each took his censer and put fire in it, put incense on it, and offered profane fire before the LORD, which He had not commanded them. 2 So fire went out from the LORD and devoured them, and they died before the LORD. 3 And Moses said to Aaron, "This is what the LORD spoke, saying: 'By those who come near Me I must be regarded as holy; And before all the people I must be glorified.'" So Aaron held his peace.Leviticus 10:1–3
Nadab and Abihu weren't worshiping idols. They were offering incense to the true God. Their sin was doing it their own way, with fire "which He had not commanded them." And God's word to Aaron is the rule for all worship, then and now: "By those who come near Me I must be regarded as holy; and before all the people I must be glorified." Him. Not the men doing the offering.
When Isaiah saw the Lord on His throne, with the seraphim covering their faces and crying "Holy, holy, holy," he didn't feel good. He said, "Woe is me, for I am undone!" (Isaiah 6:5). That's what happens to a man who actually stands in the presence of God.
The Fathers on standing before Him
The Didache, the teaching of the Apostles, which the early Church read alongside Scripture, gives the rule for every Sunday.
The Didache: that your sacrifice may be pure
"But every Lord's day gather yourselves together, and break bread, and give thanksgiving after having confessed your transgressions, that your sacrifice may be pure. But let no one that is at variance with his fellow come together with you, until they be reconciled, that your sacrifice may not be profaned. For this is that which was spoken by the Lord: In every place and time offer to me a pure sacrifice; for I am a great King, says the Lord, and my name is wonderful among the nations."
The Didache 14
Every Lord's Day. Break bread. Confess your sins first. Be reconciled with your brother first, just as Christ commanded (Matthew 5:23–24). And the Didache calls it what it is: a sacrifice, the "pure offering" God promised through the prophet.
The text behind the Didache
"For from the rising of the sun, even to its going down, My name shall be great among the Gentiles; In every place incense shall be offered to My name, And a pure offering; For My name shall be great among the nations," Says the LORD of hosts.
Malachi 1:11
Malachi prophesied a day when a pure offering would be made to God "in every place," among the nations, not just at the Temple in Jerusalem. The Apostles' own teaching says that day came with the Eucharist offered every Lord's Day.
And here's St Justin again, in the chapter right after the one you read in Session 4, describing what a whole Sunday looked like around AD 155.
St Justin Martyr: what Sunday looked like
"And on the day called Sunday, all who live in cities or in the country gather together to one place, and the memoirs of the apostles or the writings of the prophets are read, as long as time permits; then, when the reader has ceased, the president verbally instructs, and exhorts to the imitation of these good things. Then we all rise together and pray, and, as we before said, when our prayer is ended, bread and wine and water are brought, and the president in like manner offers prayers and thanksgivings, according to his ability, and the people assent, saying Amen; and there is a distribution to each, and a participation of that over which thanks have been given, and to those who are absent a portion is sent by the deacons."
First Apology 67
Look at where the sermon falls. Scripture is read "as long as time permits." Then the president "instructs, and exhorts to the imitation of these good things," and that's it for him. He points them to the Scriptures they just heard. Then they all rise, pray, and the Eucharist is offered and received. The preaching is one piece, in the middle, and it points back at the Word and forward to the altar. That's the shape the Divine Liturgy still has today.
St Cyril, teaching the newly baptized how to come up and receive, shows you what reverence looks like in the hands.
St Cyril of Jerusalem: a throne for a King
"In approaching therefore, come not with your wrists extended, or your fingers spread; but make your left hand a throne for the right, as for that which is to receive a King. And having hollowed your palm, receive the Body of Christ, saying over it, Amen... For tell me, if any one gave you grains of gold, would you not hold them with all carefulness, being on your guard against losing any of them, and suffering loss? Will you not then much more carefully keep watch, that not a crumb fall from you of what is more precious than gold and precious stones?"
Catechetical Lecture 23 (Mystagogical Lecture 5), 21
"A throne... to receive a King." Not a crumb dropped. That's how you treat something when you actually believe it's Him.
St John Chrysostom: are you still on earth?
"For when you see the Lord sacrificed, and laid upon the altar, and the priest standing and praying over the victim, and all the worshippers empurpled with that precious blood, can you then think that you are still among men, and standing upon the earth? Are you not, on the contrary, straightway translated to Heaven, and casting out every carnal thought from the soul, do you not with disembodied spirit and pure reason contemplate the things which are in Heaven? Oh! What a marvel! What love of God to man! He who sits on high with the Father is at that hour held in the hands of all, and gives Himself to those who are willing to embrace and grasp Him. And this all do through the eyes of faith!"
On the Priesthood, Book III
This is the whole difference in one paragraph. Not "God is with us" as a sentiment. "Can you then think that you are still among men, and standing upon the earth?" In the Liturgy the Church stands in heaven. And notice where the priest is: "standing and praying over the victim." He isn't the one being looked at. Christ is.
And when Chrysostom made his case against applause in church, the clincher was the Eucharist itself.
St John Chrysostom: during the Mysteries
"Say, during the celebration of the Mysteries, is there any noise? Any disturbance? When we are baptizing, when we are doing all the other acts? Is not all Nature decked (as it were) with stillness and silence? Over all the face of heaven is scattered this charm (of repose). On this account are we evil spoken of even among the Gentiles, as though we did all for display and ostentation. But if this be prevented, the love of the chief seats also will be extinguished."
Homily 30 on the Acts of the Apostles
"As though we did all for display and ostentation." Even the pagans could tell when the Church was putting on a show. And look at what Chrysostom says stopping the show would kill: "the love of the chief seats." Take away the performance, and you take away the ladder men climb to get noticed.
St Clement said it at the end of the first century: God "has enjoined offerings [to be presented] and service to be performed [to Him], and that not thoughtlessly or irregularly, but at the appointed times and hours. Where and by whom He desires these things to be done, He Himself has fixed by His own supreme will" (Letter to the Corinthians 40). Worship isn't ours to invent. We don't design it to draw a crowd. We receive it, and we offer it back.
Sit with these
- Paul says unworthy reception makes a man "guilty of the body and blood of the Lord" (1 Corinthians 11:27). Could that be said about a symbol?
- Hebrews says "you have come" to the heavenly Jerusalem (Hebrews 12:22). How would you walk into church if you believed that?
- The church in Antioch "ministered to the Lord" (Acts 13:2). Who is a Sunday service for?
- Nadab and Abihu worshiped the right God the wrong way (Leviticus 10:1). Why does God care how He's worshiped, and not only that He is?
- Chrysostom says ending the show would kill "the love of the chief seats." What's the connection between entertainment and men climbing for position?
Carry this
"By those who come near Me I must be regarded as holy." We don't come to church to be reminded God is nearby. We come to stand before Him, and serve Him, with reverence and godly fear.
Session six
Answerable to No One
Read these first, in this order
Numbers 16:1–3 · 3 John 1:9–11 · Acts 14:21–23 · Titus 1:5–9 · Acts 15:1–6, 22–29 · 1 Timothy 5:17–22 · Hebrews 13:17 · 2 Peter 2:1–3 · Ezekiel 34:1–10 · 1 Peter 5:1–4
Most of these churches are independent by design. The pastor answers to a board inside his own four walls, often a board he helped pick. Scripture never once describes a church like that, and the first thing the Apostles did everywhere they went was make sure no church would ever be one.
The last five sessions showed you what goes wrong. This one shows you how it's allowed to happen. A man can only become the center of a church if there's nobody above him to say no.
The oldest argument against order
The first rebellion against God's order in worship came in the wilderness, and the rebels' argument will sound familiar.
1 Now Korah the son of Izhar, the son of Kohath, the son of Levi, with Dathan and Abiram the sons of Eliab, and On the son of Peleth, sons of Reuben, took men; 2 and they rose up before Moses with some of the children of Israel, two hundred and fifty leaders of the congregation, representatives of the congregation, men of renown. 3 They gathered together against Moses and Aaron, and said to them, "You take too much upon yourselves, for all the congregation is holy, every one of them, and the LORD is among them. Why then do you exalt yourselves above the assembly of the LORD?"Numbers 16:1–3
"All the congregation is holy, every one of them... why then do you exalt yourselves?" It sounds humble. It sounds like equality. What it really meant was: nobody's over us. God answered by opening the ground under them (Numbers 16:31–33). The New Testament names it as a pattern for false teachers in the Church: they "perished in the rebellion of Korah" (Jude 1:11). And St Clement tells the Corinthians that Moses settled the question of who serves at the altar by Aaron's rod budding, "that there might be no sedition in Israel" (Letter to the Corinthians 43).
The man who loved first place
By the end of the first century, the Apostles had already met the independent pastor.
9 I wrote to the church, but Diotrephes, who loves to have the preeminence among them, does not receive us. 10 Therefore, if I come, I will call to mind his deeds which he does, prating against us with malicious words. And not content with that, he himself does not receive the brethren, and forbids those who wish to, putting them out of the church.3 John 1:9–10
Diotrephes is the cult of personality in the first century, and St John tells you exactly what drives him: he "loves to have the preeminence." He loves being first. So he won't receive the Apostle's authority. He talks trash about the men over him. And he runs his church like it's his, throwing out anybody who doesn't go along. But look at John's answer: "if I come, I will call to mind his deeds." Diotrephes could be called to account because there was someone above him who could come and do it. Take away the Apostle, and Diotrephes is untouchable.
Appointed, not self-appointed
Now watch what the Apostles actually did when they planted churches.
So when they had appointed elders in every church, and prayed with fasting, they commended them to the Lord in whom they had believed.Acts 14:23
For this reason I left you in Crete, that you should set in order the things that are lacking, and appoint elders in every city as I commanded you.Titus 1:5
Paul and Barnabas appointed elders "in every church." Paul left Titus in Crete to appoint elders "in every city," and notice: "as I commanded you." Titus answered to Paul. The elders answered to Titus. Nobody appointed himself. "How shall they preach unless they are sent?" (Romans 10:15). In the New Testament, a shepherd is sent by the Church. He doesn't rent a building, start a church and hand himself the title.
And when a real dispute came up, a local church didn't settle it by itself. When the church in Antioch was torn over whether Gentile converts had to be circumcised, they sent Paul and Barnabas up to Jerusalem, "and the apostles and elders came together to consider this matter" (Acts 15:6). The council's decision went out to all the churches with these words: "it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us" (Acts 15:28). The Church above the local church decided, and the local church received it.
Paul even tells Timothy how to handle an elder who's accused of sin: "Do not receive an accusation against an elder except from two or three witnesses. Those who are sinning rebuke in the presence of all, that the rest also may fear" (1 Timothy 5:19–20). Somebody has to be in a position to hear the charge and rebuke the elder. And Hebrews says the shepherds themselves "must give account" (Hebrews 13:17). Give account to whom? In an independent church, the honest answer is often: nobody on this earth.
What the Apostles set up so this couldn't happen
St Clement, writing to that same divided church in Corinth, tells them the Apostles saw all of this coming.
St Clement of Rome: sent, and sent again
"The apostles have preached the gospel to us from the Lord Jesus Christ; Jesus Christ [has done so] from God. Christ therefore was sent forth by God, and the apostles by Christ. Both these appointments, then, were made in an orderly way, according to the will of God... And thus preaching through countries and cities, they appointed the first fruits [of their labours], having first proved them by the Spirit, to be bishops and deacons of those who should afterwards believe."
Letter to the Corinthians 42
"Our apostles also knew, through our Lord Jesus Christ, that there would be strife on account of the office of the episcopate. For this reason, therefore, inasmuch as they had obtained a perfect fore-knowledge of this, they appointed those [ministers] already mentioned, and afterwards gave instructions, that when these should fall asleep, other approved men should succeed them in their ministry."
Letter to the Corinthians 44
God sent Christ. Christ sent the Apostles. The Apostles appointed bishops, and "gave instructions" so that when those men died, "other approved men should succeed them." That's apostolic succession, described by a man who knew the Apostles. And look at why they did it: they "knew... that there would be strife on account of the office." They knew men would fight to be in charge. So they made sure nobody could just take the office. It had to be handed on.
St Ignatius of Antioch: nothing without the bishop
"See that you all follow the bishop, even as Jesus Christ does the Father, and the presbytery as you would the apostles; and reverence the deacons, as being the institution of God. Let no man do anything connected with the Church without the bishop. Let that be deemed a proper Eucharist, which is [administered] either by the bishop, or by one to whom he has entrusted it. Wherever the bishop shall appear, there let the multitude [of the people] also be; even as, wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church."
Epistle to the Smyrnaeans 8
For Ignatius, a church without a bishop wasn't a church with a different style. A Eucharist nobody was sent to offer wasn't "a proper Eucharist." The authority to stand at the altar comes from being sent by the Church, not from a man's gifts or his following.
St Irenaeus, around AD 180, used the same thing to answer the false teachers of his day.
St Irenaeus of Lyons: unauthorized meetings
"It is within the power of all, therefore, in every Church, who may wish to see the truth, to contemplate clearly the tradition of the apostles manifested throughout the whole world; and we are in a position to reckon up those who were by the apostles instituted bishops in the Churches, and [to demonstrate] the succession of these men to our own times... we do put to confusion all those who, in whatever manner, whether by an evil self-pleasing, by vainglory, or by blindness and perverse opinion, assemble in unauthorized meetings."
Against Heresies III.3.1–2
"An evil self-pleasing, by vainglory." Irenaeus names two of the reasons men start churches nobody sent them to start. And his answer is the same one Clement gave: you can trace the Church's bishops back to the men the Apostles appointed. (He goes on from there to give the church of Rome, founded by Peter and Paul, as his example of that succession.)
Here's the honest truth, the same standard for everyone: priests fall too. A man in a cassock can love the chief seats just as much as any pastor on a stage. Hierarchy doesn't make anybody sinless. What it does is make sure that when a priest falls, there's a bishop who can remove him, and a bishop answers to his brother bishops, and all of them answer to what the Church has always taught. The Church has two thousand years of canons for exactly that. An independent pastor who falls answers to a board in his own building. That's the difference, and it's the whole difference.
Then the money follows
When a man answers to no one, the church becomes his, and so does what comes in. Scripture saw that coming too.
1 But there were also false prophets among the people, even as there will be false teachers among you, who will secretly bring in destructive heresies, even denying the Lord who bought them, and bring on themselves swift destruction. 2 And many will follow their destructive ways, because of whom the way of truth will be blasphemed. 3 By covetousness they will exploit you with deceptive words; for a long time their judgment has not been idle, and their destruction does not slumber.2 Peter 2:1–3
"Many will follow." "By covetousness they will exploit you." Paul warns Timothy about men "who suppose that godliness is a means of gain. From such withdraw yourself" (1 Timothy 6:5). And the Didache, the Apostles' own teaching, gave the early Church a test so simple you could use it this Sunday.
The Didache: if he asks for money
"Let every apostle that comes to you be received as the Lord. But he shall not remain except one day; but if there be need, also the next; but if he remain three days, he is a false prophet. And when the apostle goes away, let him take nothing but bread until he lodges; but if he ask money, he is a false prophet."
The Didache 11
"Therefore, appoint for yourselves bishops and deacons worthy of the Lord, men meek, and not lovers of money, and truthful and proven."
The Didache 15
"If he ask money, he is a false prophet." "Not lovers of money." The Apostles' first test for a man who wanted to lead God's people was what he wanted from them. The Church has always supported her clergy. The question is whether the man is serving the flock or the flock is serving him.
The shepherds who feed themselves
God said it through Ezekiel, to the leaders of His people, and He wasn't gentle.
2 "Son of man, prophesy against the shepherds of Israel, prophesy and say to them, 'Thus says the Lord GOD to the shepherds: "Woe to the shepherds of Israel who feed themselves! Should not the shepherds feed the flocks? 3 You eat the fat and clothe yourselves with the wool; you slaughter the fatlings, but you do not feed the flock. 4 The weak you have not strengthened, nor have you healed those who were sick, nor bound up the broken, nor brought back what was driven away, nor sought what was lost; but with force and cruelty you have ruled them."Ezekiel 34:2–4
"Shepherds... who feed themselves." That's where the road ends, every time, when a man becomes the center: the flock exists for him. And here's the other road, from the Apostle Christ told to feed His sheep.
1 The elders who are among you I exhort, I who am a fellow elder and a witness of the sufferings of Christ, and also a partaker of the glory that will be revealed: 2 Shepherd the flock of God which is among you, serving as overseers, not by compulsion but willingly, not for dishonest gain but eagerly; 3 nor as being lords over those entrusted to you, but being examples to the flock; 4 and when the Chief Shepherd appears, you will receive the crown of glory that does not fade away.1 Peter 5:1–4
"The flock of God." Not the pastor's flock. "Not for dishonest gain." "Nor as being lords." And the crown doesn't come on Sunday, in applause. It comes "when the Chief Shepherd appears." Peter calls himself "a fellow elder," and he points every eye to the One who is Chief.
Where Christ is the center
So here's the way home, and it's the same thing the whole study has been pointing at. In the Divine Liturgy, the priest didn't choose himself. He was sent by a bishop, who was consecrated by bishops, back to the men the Apostles appointed. He says the same prayers every week that were said before he was born, so the service doesn't rise or fall on his personality. He stands facing the altar with the people, not facing them like a performer. And at the center of it all is Christ, truly present in His Body and Blood, the reason everyone came. There's no room in that for a cult of personality, because the only Person at the center already has the whole room's attention.
Sit with these
- Korah said, "all the congregation is holy... why then do you exalt yourselves?" (Numbers 16:3). Why does rejecting all authority often end with one man in charge?
- Diotrephes "loves to have the preeminence" (3 John 1:9). What made it possible for John to call him to account?
- In Acts and Titus, elders are appointed by the Apostles and those they sent. Who appoints the pastor of an independent church? Who can remove him?
- Clement says the Apostles set up succession because they knew "there would be strife on account of the office." What does that tell you about why the structure exists?
- Peter tells the elders to shepherd "the flock of God" and not to be "lords over" them (1 Peter 5:2–3). Whose flock is it in your church?
Carry this
"Christ therefore was sent forth by God, and the apostles by Christ." A shepherd is sent, and he answers to the Church that sent him. A man who answers to no one will end up with a church that answers to him.
A personal word
My 2 Cents
I grew up in a non-denominational church. I was taught by a pastor who'd had it taught to him, and I never once questioned what came from that stage. I'm not writing this to mock anybody sitting in those seats. I sat in them. Most of the people there love God and showed up every week because they wanted to hear about Him.
But I have to be honest about it now. I trusted the man in front more than I ever thought to check him against the Church that gave us the Bible in the first place. What he said was what the Bible said, as far as I knew. I'd never heard of the Fathers. I'd never asked who sent him, or who he answered to. It just never came up.
Then I read John 6. "My flesh is food indeed, and My blood is drink indeed." And I read what the men who knew the Apostles actually believed, and what Sunday looked like for them. Scripture, prayers, and then the altar. Christ at the center. The man in front pointing at Him and getting out of the way.
That's what I want for everybody who grew up where I did. Not a better preacher. Not a better band. Him. The One Paul was talking about when he asked, "Was Paul crucified for you?"
He must increase, and every one of us must decrease. Come and see where He's been the center the whole time. Amen.
The author's own reflection, offered alongside the study rather than as part of its argument.
Reference
The witnesses, by work and section
Every citation is given by work and section so you can check it. If you're going to quote something, verify it first. Quotes from the Fathers float around online in mangled and made-up forms, and getting caught with a fake quote costs you more than the quote was ever worth.
The Fathers of the early Church
| Witness | Work and section | What it supports | Session |
|---|---|---|---|
| St Clement of Rome (d. c. 99) | Letter to the Corinthians 30, 47 | "Let our praise be in God, and not of ourselves"; "that inclination for one above another" | 1 |
| St Clement of Rome | Letter to the Corinthians 40, 42, 43, 44 | Worship "not thoughtlessly or irregularly"; Christ sent by God, the apostles by Christ; bishops appointed, "other approved men should succeed them" | 5, 6 |
| The Didache (late 1st / early 2nd c.) | Chapters 11, 14, 15 | "If he ask money, he is a false prophet"; confess sins "that your sacrifice may be pure"; bishops "not lovers of money" | 5, 6 |
| St Ignatius of Antioch (d. c. 107) | Epistle to the Smyrnaeans 6, 7, 8 | "Let not [high] place puff any one up"; the Eucharist "the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ"; "Let no man do anything connected with the Church without the bishop" | 1, 4, 6 |
| St Justin Martyr (d. c. 165) | First Apology 66, 67 | "Not as common bread and common drink"; the shape of Sunday worship | 4, 5 |
| St Irenaeus of Lyons (c. 130–202) | Against Heresies III.3.1–2 | The succession of bishops from the apostles; those who "by vainglory... assemble in unauthorized meetings" | 6 |
| St Cyril of Jerusalem (c. 313–386) | Catechetical Lectures 22 and 23 (Mystagogical Lectures 4 and 5) | "Not as bare elements"; "make your left hand a throne... to receive a King" | 4, 5 |
| St John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) | Homilies 30 and 31 on the Acts of the Apostles | The Apostles "clean from the lust of glory"; "This has turned the Churches upside down"; "Noise belongs to theatres"; silence during the Mysteries | 1, 2, 3, 5 |
| St John Chrysostom | On the Priesthood, Books III and V | "Can you then think that you are still among men"; the public "sitting like critics of tragedies"; "indifference to their praise" | 3, 5 |
Where to read them
- Clement of Rome, Letter to the Corinthians, chapters 30, 40–44 and 47
- The Didache, chapters 11, 14 and 15
- Ignatius of Antioch, Epistle to the Smyrnaeans, chapters 6–8
- Justin Martyr, First Apology, chapters 66 and 67
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies III.3, sections 1 and 2
- Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lecture 22 · Lecture 23
- Chrysostom, Homily 30 on the Acts of the Apostles · Homily 31
- Chrysostom, On the Priesthood, Book III · Book V
Reading them rightly
The Fathers are witnesses to how the Church read Scripture. They're not a second source of revelation. Their weight here comes from how they add up. Clement in Rome, the Didache in Syria, Ignatius in Antioch, Justin in Rome, Irenaeus in Gaul, Cyril in Jerusalem, Chrysostom in Antioch and Constantinople: across three centuries and across the whole Christian world, they say the same things. The Eucharist is the Body and Blood of Christ. Worship is offered to God with reverence, not staged for a crowd. And the men who lead the Church are sent, and answer to the Church that sent them. That agreement is the argument.